Al Achkar Morhaf, Hanauer Mathew, Morrison Elizabeth H, Davies M Kelly, Oh Robert C
Department of Family Medicine-Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN, USA.
Health Sciences, University of California, Riverside School of Medicine, Riverside, CA, USA.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2017 Apr 28;8:299-306. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S127007. eCollection 2017.
Teaching residents how to teach is a critical part of residents' training in graduate medical education (GME). The purpose of this study was to assess the change in resident-as-teacher (RaT) instruction in GME over the past 15 years in the US.
We used a quantitative and qualitative survey of all program directors (PDs) across specialties. We compared our findings with a previous work from 2000-2001 that studied the same matter. Finally, we qualitatively analyzed PDs' responses regarding the reasons for implementing and not implementing RaT instruction.
Two hundred and twenty-one PDs completed the survey, which yields a response rate of 12.6%. Over 80% of PDs implement RaT, an increase of 26.34% compared to 2000-2001. RaT instruction uses multiple methods with didactic lectures reported as the most common, followed by role playing in simulated environments, then observing and giving feedback. Residents giving feedback, clinical supervision, and bedside teaching were the top three targeted skills. Through our qualitative analysis we identified five main reasons for implementing RaT: teaching is part of the residents' role; learners desire formal RaT training; regulatory bodies require RaT training; RaT improves residents' education; and RaT prepares residents for their current and future roles.
The use of RaT instruction has increased significantly in GME. More and more PDs are realizing its importance in the residents' formative training experience. Future studies should examine the effectiveness of each method for RaT instruction.
教导住院医师如何教学是毕业后医学教育(GME)中住院医师培训的关键部分。本研究的目的是评估过去15年美国GME中住院医师作为教师(RaT)教学的变化情况。
我们对各专业的所有项目主任(PD)进行了定量和定性调查。我们将研究结果与2000 - 2001年一项研究同一问题的先前工作进行了比较。最后,我们对PD关于实施和不实施RaT教学的原因的回答进行了定性分析。
221名PD完成了调查,回复率为12.6%。超过80%的PD实施RaT,与2000 - 2001年相比增加了26.34%。RaT教学使用多种方法,其中讲授式讲座是最常见的,其次是在模拟环境中进行角色扮演,然后是观察和给予反馈。住院医师给予反馈、临床监督和床边教学是三大目标技能。通过定性分析,我们确定了实施RaT的五个主要原因:教学是住院医师职责的一部分;学习者希望接受正式的RaT培训;监管机构要求进行RaT培训;RaT改善住院医师教育;RaT使住院医师为其当前和未来的角色做好准备。
GME中RaT教学的使用显著增加。越来越多的PD意识到其在住院医师形成性培训经历中的重要性。未来的研究应考察每种RaT教学方法的有效性。