Kyle Richard G, Medford Wayne, Blundell Julie, Webster Elaine, Munoz Sarah-Anne, Macaden Leah
School of Health and Social Care, Edinburgh Napier University, UK.
School of Medicine, Pharmacy and Health, Durham University, UK.
Nurse Educ Pract. 2017 Jul;25:50-56. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2017.05.001. Epub 2017 May 4.
Guarding against loss of human dignity is fundamental to nursing practice. It is assumed in the existing literature that 'dignity' as a concept and 'dignity in care' as a practice is amenable to education. Building on this assumption, a range of experiential and experimental educational approaches have been used to enhance students' understanding of dignity. However, little is known about student nurses' views on whether dignity is amenable to education and, if so, which educational approaches would be welcomed. This mixed-methods study used an online questionnaire survey and focus groups to address these questions. Student nurses in Scotland completed online questionnaires (n = 111) and participated in focus groups (n = 35). Students concluded that education has transformative potential to encourage learning around the concept of dignity and practice of dignity in care but also believed that dignity could be unlearned through repeated negative practice exposures. Experiential and experimental educational approaches were welcomed by student nurses, including patient testimony, role-play, simulation, and empathy exercises to step into the lives of others. Nurse educators should further integrate experiential and experimental educational approaches into undergraduate and postgraduate nursing curricula to guard against the loss of learning around dignity students believed occurred over time.
防范人的尊严丧失是护理实践的根本。现有文献认为,“尊严”这一概念以及“护理中的尊严”这一实践是可以通过教育来实现的。基于这一假设,一系列体验式和实验性教育方法已被用于增强学生对尊严的理解。然而,对于实习护士是否认为尊严可以通过教育来实现,以及如果可以,哪些教育方法会受到欢迎,我们却知之甚少。这项混合方法研究使用了在线问卷调查和焦点小组来解决这些问题。苏格兰的实习护士完成了在线问卷(n = 111)并参加了焦点小组(n = 35)。学生们得出结论,教育具有变革潜力,既能鼓励围绕尊严概念的学习,也能促进护理中尊严实践的学习,但他们也认为,通过反复接触负面实践,尊严可能会被磨灭。实习护士欢迎体验式和实验性教育方法,包括患者证言、角色扮演、模拟以及设身处地体验他人生活的共情练习。护理教育工作者应进一步将体验式和实验性教育方法融入本科和研究生护理课程,以防止学生认为随着时间推移会出现的围绕尊严的学习缺失。