Iijima Masaya
Department of Natural History Sciences, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Hokkaido, Japan.
J Anat. 2017 Aug;231(2):192-211. doi: 10.1111/joa.12626. Epub 2017 May 18.
Although the establishment of trophic ecomorphology in living crocodylians can contribute to estimating feeding habits of extinct large aquatic reptiles, assessment of ecomorphological traits other than the snout shape has scarcely been conducted in crocodylians. Here, I tested the validity of the proposed trophic ecomorphological traits in crocodylians by examining the correlation between those traits and the snout shape (an established trophic ecomorphology), using 10 non-alligatoroid crocodylian species with a wide range of snout shape. I then compared the ontogenetic scaling of trophic ecomorphology to discuss its adaptive and taxonomic significance. The results demonstrated that degree of heterodonty, tooth spacing, size of supratemporal fenestra (STF), ventral extension of pterygoid flange and length of lower jaw symphysis are significantly correlated with snout shape by both non-phylogenetic and phylogenetic regression analyses. Gavialis gangeticus falls outside of 95% prediction intervals for the relationships of some traits and the snout shape, suggesting that piscivorous specialization involves the deviation from the typical transformation axis of skull characters. The comparative snout shape ontogeny revealed a universal trend of snout widening through growth in the sampled crocodylians, implying the existence of a shared size-dependent biomechanical constraint in non-alligatoroid crocodylians. Growth patterns of other traits indicated that G. gangeticus shows atypical trends for degree of heterodonty, size of STF, and symphysis length, whereas the same trends are shared for tooth spacing and ventral extension of pterygoid flange among non-alligatoroid crocodylians. These suggest that some characters are ontogenetically labile in response to prey preference shifts through growth, but other characters are in keeping with the conserved biomechanics among non-alligatoroid crocodylians. Some important taxonomic characters such as the occlusal pattern are likely correlated with ontogeny and trophic ecomorphology rather than are constrained by phylogenetic relationships, and careful reassessment of such characters might be necessary for better reconstructing the morphological phylogeny of crocodylians.
虽然现存鳄形目动物营养生态形态学的建立有助于估计已灭绝大型水生爬行动物的食性,但除吻部形状外,鳄形目动物其他生态形态学特征的评估却鲜有开展。在此,我通过研究10种吻部形状差异较大的非短吻鳄类鳄形目物种的这些特征与吻部形状(一种已确立的营养生态形态学特征)之间的相关性,来检验鳄形目动物中所提出的营养生态形态学特征的有效性。然后,我比较了营养生态形态学的个体发育尺度,以探讨其适应性和分类学意义。结果表明,通过非系统发育和系统发育回归分析,异型齿程度、齿间距、颞上孔(STF)大小、翼骨凸缘的腹侧延伸以及下颌联合长度均与吻部形状显著相关。恒河鳄在某些特征与吻部形状的关系上超出了95%的预测区间,这表明食鱼特化涉及到与头骨特征典型转变轴的偏离。比较吻部形状个体发育过程发现,在采样的鳄形目动物中普遍存在随着生长吻部变宽的趋势,这意味着在非短吻鳄类鳄形目动物中存在共同的与大小相关的生物力学限制。其他特征的生长模式表明,恒河鳄在异型齿程度、STF大小和联合长度方面呈现非典型趋势,而非短吻鳄类鳄形目动物在齿间距和翼骨凸缘的腹侧延伸方面具有相同趋势。这些表明,一些特征在个体发育过程中因生长过程中猎物偏好的转变而不稳定,但其他特征与非短吻鳄类鳄形目动物中保守的生物力学一致。一些重要的分类学特征,如咬合模式,可能与个体发育和营养生态形态学相关,而不是受系统发育关系的限制,为了更好地重建鳄形目动物的形态系统发育,可能有必要对这些特征进行仔细的重新评估。