Adams Emma J, Chalkley Anna E, Esliger Dale W, Sherar Lauren B
National Centre for Sport and Exercise Medicine, School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences, Loughborough University, Loughborough, UK.
BMC Public Health. 2017 May 18;17(1):466. doi: 10.1186/s12889-017-4376-7.
Promoting walking for the journey to/from work and during the working day is one potential approach to increase physical activity in adults. Walking Works was a practice-led, whole-workplace walking programme delivered by employees (walking champions). This study aimed to evaluate the implementation of Walking Works using the RE-AIM framework and provide recommendations for future delivery of whole-workplace walking programmes.
Two cross sectional surveys were conducted; 1544 (28%) employees completed the baseline survey and 918 employees (21%) completed the follow-up survey. Effectiveness was assessed using baseline and follow-up data; reach, implementation and maintenance were assessed using follow-up data only. For categorical data, Chi square tests were conducted to assess differences between surveys or groups. Continuous data were analysed to test for significant differences using a Mann-Whitney U test. Telephone interviews were conducted with the lead organisation co-ordinator, eight walking champions and three business representatives at follow-up. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed to identify key themes related to adoption, implementation and maintenance.
Adoption: Five workplaces participated in Walking Works. Reach: 480 (52.3%) employees were aware of activities and 221 (24.1%) participated.
A variety of walking activities were delivered. Some programme components were not delivered as planned which was partly due to barriers in using walking champions to deliver activities. These included the walking champions' capacity, skills, support needs, ability to engage senior management, and the number and type of activities they could deliver. Other barriers included lack of management support, difficulties communicating information about activities and challenges embedding the programme into normal business activities. Effectiveness: No significant changes in walking to/from work or walking during the working day were observed. Maintenance: Plans to continue activities were mainly dependent on identifying continued funding.
RE-AIM provided a useful framework for evaluating Walking Works. No changes in walking behaviour were observed. This may have been due to barriers in using walking champions to deliver activities, programme components not being delivered as intended, the types of activities delivered, or lack of awareness and participation by employees. Recommendations are provided for researchers and practitioners implementing future whole-workplace walking programmes.
鼓励在上下班途中及工作日期间步行是增加成年人身体活动的一种潜在方法。“步行计划”是一项由员工(步行倡导者)主导实施的全工作场所步行计划。本研究旨在使用RE-AIM框架评估“步行计划”的实施情况,并为未来全工作场所步行计划的实施提供建议。
进行了两项横断面调查;1544名(28%)员工完成了基线调查,918名员工(21%)完成了随访调查。使用基线和随访数据评估有效性;仅使用随访数据评估覆盖范围、实施情况和维持情况。对于分类数据,进行卡方检验以评估调查或组之间的差异。使用曼-惠特尼U检验分析连续数据以检验显著差异。在随访时对牵头组织协调员、八位步行倡导者和三位企业代表进行了电话访谈。访谈内容逐字记录并进行分析,以确定与采用、实施和维持相关的关键主题。
采用情况:五个工作场所参与了“步行计划”。覆盖范围:480名(52.3%)员工知晓活动,221名(24.1%)员工参与了活动。
开展了多种步行活动。一些计划组成部分未按计划实施,部分原因是利用步行倡导者开展活动存在障碍。这些障碍包括步行倡导者的能力、技能、支持需求、与高级管理层沟通的能力,以及他们能够开展的活动的数量和类型。其他障碍包括缺乏管理层支持、活动信息沟通困难以及将该计划融入正常业务活动面临挑战。有效性:在上下班步行或工作日期间步行方面未观察到显著变化。维持情况:继续开展活动的计划主要取决于能否获得持续资金。
RE-AIM为评估“步行计划”提供了一个有用的框架。未观察到步行行为的变化。这可能是由于利用步行倡导者开展活动存在障碍、计划组成部分未按预期实施、所开展活动类型的原因,或者员工缺乏意识和参与度。为实施未来全工作场所步行计划的研究人员和从业者提供了建议。