Steensels Machteld, Maltz Ephraim, Bahr Claudia, Berckmans Daniel, Antler Aharon, Halachmi Ilan
Institute of Agricultural Engineering - Agricultural Research Organization (ARO) - The Volcani Center,PO Box 6,Bet-Dagan 50250,Israel.
Department of Biosystems (BIOSYST),KU Leuven,Kasteelpark Arenberg 30 - bus 2456,3001 Heverlee,Belgium.
J Dairy Res. 2017 May;84(2):139-145. doi: 10.1017/S0022029917000188.
The objective of this study was to design and validate a mathematical model to detect post-calving ketosis. The validation was conducted in four commercial dairy farms in Israel, on a total of 706 multiparous Holstein dairy cows: 203 cows clinically diagnosed with ketosis and 503 healthy cows. A logistic binary regression model was developed, where the dependent variable is categorical (healthy/diseased) and a set of explanatory variables were measured with existing commercial sensors: rumination duration, activity and milk yield of each individual cow. In a first validation step (within-farm), the model was calibrated on the database of each farm separately. Two thirds of the sick cows and an equal number of healthy cows were randomly selected for model validation. The remaining one third of the cows, which did not participate in the model validation, were used for model calibration. In order to overcome the random selection effect, this procedure was repeated 100 times. In a second (between-farms) validation step, the model was calibrated on one farm and validated on another farm. Within-farm accuracy, ranging from 74 to 79%, was higher than between-farm accuracy, ranging from 49 to 72%, in all farms. The within-farm sensitivities ranged from 78 to 90%, and specificities ranged from 71 to 74%. The between-farms sensitivities ranged from 65 to 95%. The developed model can be improved in future research, by employing other variables that can be added; or by exploring other models to achieve greater sensitivity and specificity.
本研究的目的是设计并验证一个用于检测产后酮病的数学模型。验证工作在以色列的四个商业化奶牛场进行,共涉及706头经产荷斯坦奶牛:203头临床诊断为酮病的奶牛和503头健康奶牛。构建了一个逻辑二元回归模型,其中因变量为分类变量(健康/患病),并使用现有的商用传感器测量了一组解释变量:每头奶牛的反刍时长、活动量和产奶量。在第一个验证步骤(农场内)中,该模型分别在每个农场的数据库上进行校准。随机选择三分之二的患病奶牛和相同数量的健康奶牛用于模型验证。其余未参与模型验证的三分之一奶牛用于模型校准。为了克服随机选择效应,此过程重复了100次。在第二个(农场间)验证步骤中,该模型在一个农场进行校准,并在另一个农场进行验证。在所有农场中,农场内准确率在74%至79%之间,高于农场间准确率(49%至72%)。农场内敏感性在78%至90%之间,特异性在71%至74%之间。农场间敏感性在65%至95%之间。通过采用其他可添加的变量,或探索其他模型以实现更高的敏感性和特异性,所开发的模型在未来研究中可得到改进。