Sinha Antara, Nagel Corey L, Schmidt Wolf P, Torondel Belen, Boisson Sophie, Routray Parimita, Clasen Thomas F
Faculty of Infectious and Tropical Diseases, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, WC1E 7HT, United Kingdom.
School of Public Health, Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR 97239, United States.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2017 Jul;220(5):906-915. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2017.05.004. Epub 2017 May 12.
Monitoring of sanitation programs is often limited to sanitation access and coverage, with little emphasis on use of the facilities despite increasing evidence of widespread non-use.
We assessed patterns and determinants of individual latrine use over 12 months in a low- income rural study population that had recently received latrines as part of the Government of India's Total Sanitation Campaign (TSC) in coastal Puri district in Odisha, India.
We surveyed 1938 individuals (>3years) in 310 rural households with latrines from 25 villages over 12 months. Data collection rounds were timed to correspond with the seasons. The primary outcome was reported use by each member of the household over the prior 48h. We classified use into three categories-"never", "sometimes" and "always/usually". We also assessed consistency of use over six days across the three seasons (dry cold, dry hot, rainy). We explored the association between individual and household-level variables and latrine use in any given season and longitudinally using multinomial logistic regression. We also inquired about reasons for non-use.
Overall, latrine use was poor and inconsistent. The average response probability at any given round of never use was 43.5% (95% CI=37.9, 49.1), sometimes use was 4.6% (95% CI=3.8, 5.5), and always/usual use was 51.9% (95% CI=46.2, 57.5). Only two-thirds of those who reported always/usually using a latrine in round one reported the same for all three rounds. Across all three rounds, the study population was about equally divided among those who reported never using the latrine (30.1%, 95% CI=23.0, 37.2), sometimes using the latrine (33.2%, 95% CI=28.3, 38.1) and always/usually using the latrine (36.8%, 95% CI=31.8, 41.8). The reported likelihood of always/usually versus never using the latrine was significantly greater in the dry cold season (OR=1.50, 95% CI=1.18, 1.89, p=0.001) and in the rainy season (OR=1.34, 95% CI=1.07, 1.69, p=0.012), than in the dry hot season. Across all three seasons, there was increased likelihood of always/usually and sometimes using the latrine versus never using it among females and where latrines had a door and roof. Older age groups, including those aged 41-59 years and 60+ years, and increase in household size were associated with a decreased likelihood of always/usually using the latrine versus never using it. The leading reason for non-use was a preference for open defecation.
Results highlight the low and inconsistent use of subsidized latrines built under the TSC in rural Odisha. This study identifies individual and household levels factors that may be used to target behavior change campaigns to drive consistent use of sanitation facilities by all.
卫生项目的监测通常局限于卫生设施的可及性和覆盖率,尽管越来越多的证据表明卫生设施普遍未得到使用,但对设施使用情况的关注却很少。
我们评估了印度奥里萨邦沿海普里区一个低收入农村研究人群在12个月内个人厕所使用的模式和决定因素,该人群最近作为印度政府全面卫生运动(TSC)的一部分获得了厕所。
我们在12个月内对来自25个村庄的310户有厕所的农村家庭中的1938名个体(年龄>3岁)进行了调查。数据收集轮次与季节相对应。主要结果是报告每户家庭成员在过去48小时内的使用情况。我们将使用情况分为三类——“从不”、“有时”和“总是/通常”。我们还评估了三个季节(干冷、干热、雨季)中六天内使用情况的一致性。我们使用多项逻辑回归探讨了个体和家庭层面变量与任何给定季节以及纵向厕所使用之间的关联。我们还询问了不使用的原因。
总体而言,厕所使用情况较差且不一致。在任何一轮调查中,报告从不使用的平均应答概率为43.5%(95%置信区间=37.9,49.1),有时使用为4.6%(95%置信区间=3.8,5.5),总是/通常使用为51.9%(95%置信区间=46.2,57.5)。在第一轮报告总是/通常使用厕所的人中,只有三分之二的人在所有三轮调查中都报告了相同的情况。在所有三轮调查中,报告从不使用厕所的人(30.1%,95%置信区间=23.0,37.2)、有时使用厕所的人(33.2%,95%置信区间=28.3,38.1)和总是/通常使用厕所的人(36.8%,95%置信区间=31.8,41.8)大致各占三分之一。报告总是/通常使用厕所与从不使用厕所相比的可能性在干冷季节(比值比=1.50,95%置信区间=1.18,1.89,p=0.001)和雨季(比值比=1.34,95%置信区间=1.07,1.69,p=0.012)显著高于干热季节。在所有三个季节中,女性以及有门和屋顶的厕所,总是/通常和有时使用厕所与从不使用厕所相比的可能性增加。包括41 - 59岁和60岁及以上年龄组在内的年龄较大群体以及家庭规模的增加与总是/通常使用厕所与从不使用厕所相比的可能性降低有关。不使用的主要原因是偏好露天排便。
结果凸显了奥里萨邦农村地区在TSC项目下建造的补贴厕所使用情况不佳且不一致的问题。本研究确定了个体和家庭层面的因素,这些因素可用于针对行为改变运动,以促使所有人持续使用卫生设施。