Fraser Thomas W K, Khezri Abdolrahman, Jusdado Juan G H, Lewandowska-Sabat Anna M, Henry Theodore, Ropstad Erik
Department of Production Animal Clinical Sciences, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Oslo, Norway.
Department of Basic Science and Aquatic Medicine, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Oslo, Norway.
Toxicol Lett. 2017 Jul 5;276:62-68. doi: 10.1016/j.toxlet.2017.05.021. Epub 2017 May 18.
Alterations in zebrafish motility are used to identify neurotoxic compounds, but few have reported how methodology may affect results. To investigate this, we exposed embryos to bisphenol A (BPA) or tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) before assessing larval motility. Embryos were maintained on a day/night cycle (DN) or in constant darkness, were reared in 96 or 24 well plates (BPA only), and behavioural tests were carried out at 96, 100, or 118 (BPA only) hours post fertilisation (hpf). We found that the prior photo-regime, larval age, and/or arena size influence behavioural outcomes in response to toxicant exposure. For example, methodology determined whether 10μM BPA induced hyperactivity, hypoactivity, or had no behavioural effect. Furthermore, the minimum effect concentration was not consistent between different methodologies. Finally, we observed a mechanism previously used to explain hyperactivity following BPA exposure does not appear to explain the hypoactivity observed following minor alterations in methodology. Therefore, we demonstrate how methodology can have notable implications on dose responses and behavioural outcomes in larval zebrafish motility following identical chemical exposures. As such, our results have significant consequences for human and environmental risk assessment.
斑马鱼运动能力的改变被用于识别神经毒性化合物,但很少有人报道方法学可能如何影响结果。为了对此进行研究,我们在评估幼体运动能力之前,将胚胎暴露于双酚A(BPA)或四溴双酚A(TBBPA)。胚胎维持在昼夜循环(DN)或持续黑暗环境中,饲养于96孔或24孔板中(仅BPA实验),并在受精后96、100或118小时(仅BPA实验)进行行为测试。我们发现,之前的光照条件、幼体年龄和/或实验场地大小会影响对毒物暴露的行为反应结果。例如,方法学决定了10μM BPA是诱导多动、活动减退还是没有行为影响。此外,不同方法之间的最小效应浓度并不一致。最后,我们观察到一种先前用于解释BPA暴露后多动的机制,似乎无法解释在方法学稍有改变后观察到的活动减退。因此,我们证明了方法学如何对相同化学物质暴露后斑马鱼幼体运动能力的剂量反应和行为结果产生显著影响。因此,我们的结果对人类和环境风险评估具有重大意义。