Barouni Mohsen, Amiresmaieli Mohammad Reza, Shahravan Arash, Amini Saeed
Health Services Management Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
Health Management, Policy Making and Economics Department, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
Iran J Public Health. 2017 Apr;46(4):552-559.
During the last decades, the number of dentistry units increased significantly across the country. The aim of this study was to assess the efficiency of dental units of Iran provinces regarding dental health inputs and outputs using Data Envelopment Analysis approach.
In this applied descriptive-analytical study, the study population included all of Iran 31 provinces. The output variables included DMFT and DMFT indices of 6-12 yr old students. The data about DMFT and DMFT indices were taken from 2013 Nationwide School Pupils Screening Program. Input variables included active dental chairs located in the public sector, general dentists of public sector, general and specialist dentists of private sector by different provinces. The data were analyzed using Deap software version 2.1.
The lowest amount of scale efficiency was for Tehran Province (0.204) followed by Isfahan Province (0.205). Provinces of Isfahan, Razavi Khorasan, Kerman, Zanjan, Hamedan, Kordestan, Golestan, Yazd and Tehran, Iran had decreasing return to scale and provinces of Gilan, West Azerbaijan, Mazandaran, Fars, Kermanshah, Markazi, Lorestan, Qazvin, Sistan-and-Baluchestan, Bushehr, Alborz, Hormozgan and Khuzestan had increasing return to scale.
Despite provinces of Isfahan, Razavi Khorasan, Kerman, Zanjan, Hamedan, Kordestan, Golestan, Yazd and Tehran which had a better situation in terms of the number of dentistry chairs, public dentists, general and specialist dentists of private sector than other provinces, they had decreasing return to scale. Investment in dental primary health care, preventive and educational programs can be more cost-effective.
在过去几十年间,全国牙科诊疗单元的数量显著增加。本研究旨在运用数据包络分析方法评估伊朗各省牙科诊疗单元在口腔健康投入与产出方面的效率。
在这项应用描述性分析研究中,研究对象包括伊朗所有31个省份。产出变量包括6至12岁学生的恒牙龋失补牙数(DMFT)和乳牙龋失补牙数(dmft)指数。DMFT和dmft指数的数据取自2013年全国在校学生筛查项目。投入变量包括公共部门的活动牙科椅数量、公共部门的普通牙医数量以及不同省份私营部门的普通牙医和专科牙医数量。数据使用Deap 2.1软件进行分析。
规模效率最低的是德黑兰省(0.204),其次是伊斯法罕省(0.205)。伊朗的伊斯法罕省、拉扎维霍拉桑省、克尔曼省、赞詹省、哈马丹省、库尔德斯坦省、戈勒斯坦省、亚兹德省和德黑兰省规模报酬递减,而吉兰省、西阿塞拜疆省、马赞德兰省、法尔斯省、克尔曼沙阿省、马克azi省、洛雷斯坦省、加兹温省、锡斯坦-俾路支斯坦省、布什尔省、阿尔伯兹省、霍尔木兹甘省和胡齐斯坦省规模报酬递增。
尽管伊斯法罕省、拉扎维霍拉桑省、克尔曼省、赞詹省、哈马丹省、库尔德斯坦省、戈勒斯坦省、亚兹德省和德黑兰省在牙科诊疗椅数量、公共牙医以及私营部门的普通牙医和专科牙医数量方面比其他省份情况更好,但它们规模报酬递减。对口腔初级卫生保健、预防和教育项目的投资可能更具成本效益。