MacDonnell Judith A, Buck-McFadyen Ellen
1 York University, Toronto, ON, Canada.
2 Trent/Fleming School of Nursing, Peterborough, ON, Canada.
Policy Polit Nurs Pract. 2016 Nov;17(4):218-230. doi: 10.1177/1527154416688669. Epub 2017 Jan 19.
Recent nursing research using a critical feminist lens challenges the prevailing view of political inertia in nursing. This comparative life history study using a critical feminist lens explores the relevance of activism with four generations of Canadian nurses. Purposeful sampling of Ontario nurses resulted in 40 participants who were diverse in terms of generation, practice setting, and activist practice. Interviews and focus groups were completed with the sample of Ontario registered nurses or undergraduate and graduate nursing students: 8 Generation X, 9 Generation Y (Millennials), 20 Boomers, and 3 Overboomers. Factors such as professional norms and personal and organizational supports shaped contradictory nursing activist identities, practices, and impacts. Gendered norms, organizational dynamics, and the political landscape influenced the meanings nurses attributed to critical incidents and influences that prompted activism inside and outside the workplace, shaping the transformative potential of nursing. Despite its limitations, the study has implications for creating professional and organizational supports for consideration of health politics and policy, and spaces for dialogue to support practice and research aligned with social justice goals.
近期运用批判女性主义视角的护理研究对护理领域中政治惰性的主流观点提出了挑战。这项运用批判女性主义视角的比较生活史研究探讨了四代加拿大护士的激进主义相关性。对安大略省护士进行的有目的抽样产生了40名参与者,他们在代际、实践环境和激进主义实践方面各不相同。对安大略省注册护士或本科及研究生护理专业学生样本进行了访谈和焦点小组讨论:8名X一代,9名Y一代(千禧一代),20名婴儿潮一代,以及3名超婴儿潮一代。诸如专业规范以及个人和组织支持等因素塑造了相互矛盾的护理激进主义身份、实践和影响。性别规范、组织动态和政治格局影响了护士赋予关键事件的意义以及促使工作场所内外激进主义的影响因素,塑造了护理的变革潜力。尽管该研究存在局限性,但它对于创建专业和组织支持以考虑健康政治和政策,以及创建对话空间以支持与社会正义目标相一致的实践和研究具有启示意义。