Song Wenhao, Zhou DongSheng, Dong Jinlei
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Shandong Provincial Hospital Affiliated to Shandong University, Ji'nan, Shandong, People's Republic of China.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 Jun;96(22):e7068. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000007068.
The aim of this study was to identify risk factors for failure of limb salvage surgery in grade IIIC lower extremity injuries.A single-institution, retrospective review was performed of all patients with grade IIIC lower limb injuries presenting from January 2009 to April 2014. We gathered the data on each patient who underwent limb salvage and analyzed the final outcome for these patients (limb salvage vs secondary amputation).Grade IIIC lower limb injuries were identified in 41 patients. Primary amputation was performed in 6 patients (15%) as the initial procedure. Thirty-five patients (85%) underwent vascular reconstruction and other surgical procedures to salvage the limb. Limb salvage was successful in 23 patients (66%); 12 patients (34%) ultimately underwent secondary amputation. The median time from injury to secondary amputation was 22.5 days (range 4-380 days). The mean Mangled Extremity Severity Score (MESS) was 7.2 ± 1.5 (range 5-10). The MESS was significantly higher in the secondary amputation group compared with the limb salvage group. Additionally, statistical testing revealed that the limb ischemia time, complex fractures, rate of fasciotomy, and number of vascular reconstruction were significantly higher in the secondary amputation group. Muscle necrosis and extensive soft tissue defect were the main reasons for secondary amputation.The findings indicate that MESS of 7 or greater, complex fractures, limb ischemia time equal to or greater than 6 hours, and osteofascial compartment syndrome were associated with an increased risk of delayed amputation. The MESS is highly prognostic but not perfect; decision-making in patients with an MESS of 7 or greater should be re-evaluated for clinical use.
本研究的目的是确定III C级下肢损伤保肢手术失败的危险因素。对2009年1月至2014年4月期间所有III C级下肢损伤患者进行了单机构回顾性研究。我们收集了每位接受保肢手术患者的数据,并分析了这些患者的最终结局(保肢与二期截肢)。
共确定了41例III C级下肢损伤患者。6例患者(15%)最初接受了一期截肢手术。35例患者(85%)接受了血管重建和其他外科手术以挽救肢体。23例患者(66%)保肢成功;12例患者(34%)最终接受了二期截肢。从受伤到二期截肢的中位时间为22.5天(范围4 - 380天)。平均肢体严重损伤评分(MESS)为7.2±1.5(范围5 - 10)。二期截肢组的MESS显著高于保肢组。此外,统计检验显示,二期截肢组的肢体缺血时间、复杂骨折、筋膜切开率和血管重建次数显著更高。肌肉坏死和广泛的软组织缺损是二期截肢的主要原因。
研究结果表明,MESS评分7分及以上、复杂骨折、肢体缺血时间等于或大于6小时以及骨筋膜室综合征与延迟截肢风险增加相关。MESS具有较高的预后价值但并不完美;对于MESS评分7分及以上的患者,临床决策应重新评估。