Harn Nicholas R, Hunt Suzanne L, Hill Jacqueline, Vidoni Eric, Perry Mark, Burns Jeffrey M
From the Departments of *Radiology, †Biostatistics, and ‡Neurology, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City, KS.
Clin Nucl Med. 2017 Aug;42(8):577-581. doi: 10.1097/RLU.0000000000001693.
Establishing reliable methods for interpreting elevated cerebral amyloid-β plaque on PET scans is increasingly important for radiologists, as availability of PET imaging in clinical practice increases. We examined a 3-step method to detect plaque in cognitively normal older adults, focusing on the additive value of quantitative information during the PET scan interpretation process.
Fifty-five F-florbetapir PET scans were evaluated by 3 experienced raters. Scans were first visually interpreted as having "elevated" or "nonelevated" plaque burden ("Visual Read"). Images were then processed using a standardized quantitative analysis software (MIMneuro) to generate whole brain and region of interest SUV ratios. This "Quantitative Read" was considered elevated if at least 2 of 6 regions of interest had an SUV ratio of more than 1.1. The final interpretation combined both visual and quantitative data together ("VisQ Read"). Cohen kappa values were assessed as a measure of interpretation agreement.
Plaque was elevated in 25.5% to 29.1% of the 165 total Visual Reads. Interrater agreement was strong (kappa = 0.73-0.82) and consistent with reported values. Quantitative Reads were elevated in 45.5% of participants. Final VisQ Reads changed from initial Visual Reads in 16 interpretations (9.7%), with most changing from "nonelevated" Visual Reads to "elevated." These changed interpretations demonstrated lower plaque quantification than those initially read as "elevated" that remained unchanged. Interrater variability improved for VisQ Reads with the addition of quantitative information (kappa = 0.88-0.96).
Inclusion of quantitative information increases consistency of PET scan interpretations for early detection of cerebral amyloid-β plaque accumulation.
随着正电子发射断层扫描(PET)成像在临床实践中的应用增加,为放射科医生建立可靠的方法来解读PET扫描中升高的脑淀粉样蛋白-β斑块变得越来越重要。我们研究了一种三步法来检测认知正常的老年人中的斑块,重点关注PET扫描解读过程中定量信息的附加价值。
由3名经验丰富的评估者对55例F-氟代贝他吡PET扫描进行评估。扫描首先通过视觉解读为具有“升高”或“未升高”的斑块负荷(“视觉解读”)。然后使用标准化的定量分析软件(MIMneuro)处理图像,以生成全脑和感兴趣区域的标准化摄取值(SUV)比率。如果6个感兴趣区域中的至少2个区域的SUV比率超过1.1,则该“定量解读”被认为是升高的。最终解读将视觉和定量数据结合在一起(“视觉定量解读”)。评估Cohen kappa值作为解读一致性的度量。
在165次总视觉解读中,25.5%至29.1%的斑块升高。评估者间的一致性很强(kappa = 0.73 - 0.82),与报告的值一致。45.5%的参与者定量解读显示斑块升高。最终的视觉定量解读在16次解读(9.7%)中与初始视觉解读不同,大多数从“未升高”的视觉解读变为“升高”。这些改变的解读显示出比最初解读为“升高”且保持不变的解读更低的斑块定量。添加定量信息后,视觉定量解读的评估者间变异性得到改善(kappa = 0.88 - 0.96)。
纳入定量信息可提高PET扫描解读的一致性,用于早期检测脑淀粉样蛋白-β斑块积累。