Upper Assam Advisory Centre, Tea Research Association, Dikom-786101, Dibrugarh, Assam, India.
Upper Assam Advisory Centre, Tea Research Association, Dikom-786101, Dibrugarh, Assam, India.
J Hazard Mater. 2017 Sep 15;338:250-264. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2017.05.036. Epub 2017 May 22.
The present study provides several contamination and ecological risk indices for selected metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni and Zn) in tea (Camellia sinensis L.; cv. S.3A/3) growing soil influenced by lower to higher doses of inorganic and organic amendments. While ecological risk indices were applied, it was observed that same treatment showed different risk levels but contamination risk status did not vary significantly. All the indices showed significant correlation with heavy metals' concentration in young shoots of tea plants. As the indices characterized experimental soils with different extents of contamination, it would be important to standardize the indices with long term experiments followed by generation of new index. Therefore, we formulated a new contamination index named as Tea Research Association Heavy Metal Contamination Index (TRAHMCI) for tea growing soils. TRAHMCI is based on the probable change of metal status in soil with progress of growth of tea plant. This could be useful to negate discrepancies arised from use of various existing metal contamination indices in tea growing soils amended with different doses of fertilizers. TRAHMCI was formulated based on individual contamination factor using statistical technique and applied to the present dataset which provided a more holistic understanding of overall tea growing soil behavior. The limitation of the developed TRAHMCI index is that, the index had not been validated for other crops in our study not to claim its effective use for crops other than tea. As already mentioned, this new index had been formulated by taking tea as the test crop with above mentioned six heavy metal contents in young shoot and made tea.
本研究提供了几种受低剂量至高剂量无机和有机改良剂影响的茶树(Camellia sinensis L.;cv. S.3A/3)生长土壤中选定金属(Cd、Cr、Cu、Mn、Ni 和 Zn)的污染和生态风险指数。虽然应用了生态风险指数,但观察到同一处理表现出不同的风险水平,但污染风险状况没有显著差异。所有指数均与茶树幼芽中重金属浓度呈显著相关。由于这些指数描述了具有不同污染程度的实验土壤,因此重要的是要用长期实验对其进行标准化,然后生成新的指数。因此,我们为茶园土壤制定了一个新的污染指数,即茶研究协会重金属污染指数(TRAHMCI)。TRAHMCI 基于茶树生长过程中土壤中金属状态可能发生的变化。这对于消除因使用不同剂量肥料改良的茶园土壤中使用各种现有金属污染指数而产生的差异可能会很有用。TRAHMCI 是根据个体污染因子使用统计技术制定的,并应用于本数据集,这提供了对整个茶园土壤行为的更全面的理解。所开发的 TRAHMCI 指数的局限性在于,该指数尚未在我们的研究中针对其他作物进行验证,因此不能声称其对除茶叶以外的作物有效。如前所述,该新指数是通过将茶叶作为试验作物,考虑了上述六种重金属在幼芽和制成茶叶中的含量而制定的。