Nuffield Centre, University of Leeds, Worsley Building, Clarendon Way, Leeds, LS2 9NL, UK.
NHSSP, Kathmandu, Nepal.
Health Policy Plan. 2017 Oct 1;32(8):1185-1192. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czx070.
Payments to users and providers of health services are an important ingredient in attempts to promote universal health coverage in low resource settings. The maternal health programme in Nepal explicitly recognizes that ensuring universal access to safe delivery care requires policies that both ensure effective services and overcome demand-side barriers. The programme has used three innovative financing initiatives to stimulate an increase in the use of facility-based delivery: the maternity incentive scheme (2005) reimbursing women for accessing a facility, activity payments in poor districts (2006) and universal free-delivery (2009). We examine the impact of these mechanisms on access to safe delivery services. Multiple waves of the Demographic and Health Survey were merged to provide household-level cross-sectional data on maternity services. A multilevel logit model was used to investigate the roll-out of the three policies across ecological zones assuming a district-wide treatment effect. An interrupted time-series approach that includes cross sectional data on deliveries at each period is used to detect the association between outcomes and policy. The maternal Incentive programme was associated with an increase in service delivery in hill and tarai areas. A positive effect in mountain areas was detectable as a result of the supply side payments made to facilities for delivery. Although use among the non-poor increased across the country, a positive effect on the poorest population was only present in mountain areas. The beneficial impact of maternal financing policies in Nepal is skewed towards areas and households that are geographically more accessible and wealthy. Inferior services in remote areas reduce the impact of financing policies. Policy may need to be refocused on poorer, less accessible areas if improvements in access to maternal health services are to continue.
支付给卫生服务的使用者和提供者是在资源匮乏环境中努力促进全民健康覆盖的一个重要因素。尼泊尔的母婴健康方案明确认识到,确保普遍获得安全分娩护理需要有政策,既要确保服务有效,又要克服需求方的障碍。该方案采用了三项创新筹资举措,以刺激增加利用基于设施的分娩服务:产妇奖励计划(2005 年)为妇女获得服务报销费用,在贫困地区支付活动费(2006 年)和普及免费分娩(2009 年)。我们考察了这些机制对获得安全分娩服务的影响。合并了多轮人口与健康调查,提供了关于产妇服务的家庭层面的横断面数据。利用多水平逻辑斯谛回归模型,根据每个地区的服务提供情况,对这三项政策在生态区的推广情况进行了调查,假设在全地区产生治疗效果。采用包括每个时期分娩横断面数据的中断时间序列方法,以检测政策与结果之间的关系。产妇奖励计划与丘陵和特莱地区服务提供的增加有关。山区也可以看到由于向提供分娩服务的设施支付供应方费用而产生的积极影响。尽管全国范围内非贫困人群的使用有所增加,但在山区只有最贫困人群受益。尼泊尔产妇筹资政策的有益影响偏向于地理位置更便利和更富裕的地区和家庭。偏远地区服务质量较差,降低了筹资政策的影响。如果要继续改善获得产妇保健服务的机会,政策可能需要重新侧重于贫困和较难到达的地区。