Cosentino Erica, Baggio Giosuè, Kontinen Jarmo, Werning Markus
Institute of Philosophy II, Ruhr University of BochumBochum, Germany.
Department of Language and Literature, Norwegian University of Science and TechnologyTrondheim, Norway.
Front Psychol. 2017 May 26;8:813. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00813. eCollection 2017.
Contemporary semantic theories can be classified along two dimensions: (i) the way and time-course in which contextual factors influence sentence truth-conditions; and (ii) whether and to what extent comprehension involves sensory, motor and emotional processes. In order to explore this theoretical space, our ERP study investigates the time-course of the interaction between the lexically specified of a noun (the function of the object to which the noun refers to, e.g., a funnel is generally used to pour liquids into containers) and an contextually induced by the situation described in the discourse. We found that, if preceded by a neutral discourse context, a verb incongruent with the noun's telic component as in "She uses the funnel to her coat" elicited an enhanced N400 compared to a congruent verb as in "She uses the funnel to water into a container." However, if the situation introduced in the preceding discourse induced a new function for the object as an affordance (e.g., the funnel is glued to the wall and the agent wants to hang the coat), we observed a crossing-over regarding the direction of the N400 effect: comparing the affordance-inducing context with the neutral context, the N400 for the incongruent verb was significantly reduced, whereas the N400 for the congruent verb was significantly enhanced. We explain these results as a consequence of the incorporation of the contextually triggered affordance into the meaning of the noun. Combining these results with an analysis of semantic similarity values between test sentences and contexts, we argue that one possibility is that the incorporation of an affordance may be explained on the basis of the mental simulation of concurrent motor information.
(i)语境因素影响句子真值条件的方式和时间进程;(ii)理解是否以及在多大程度上涉及感觉、运动和情感过程。为了探索这一理论空间,我们的事件相关电位(ERP)研究考察了名词的词汇指定意义(名词所指对象的功能,例如,漏斗通常用于将液体倒入容器)与话语中描述的情境所引发的语境意义之间相互作用的时间进程。我们发现,如果在中性话语语境之前,与名词的目的成分不一致的动词,如“她用漏斗 她的外套”,与一致动词“她用漏斗把水倒入容器”相比,会引发增强的N400。然而,如果前序话语中引入的情境为对象赋予了一种新功能作为一种可供性(例如,漏斗粘在墙上,主体想挂外套),我们观察到N400效应方向的交叉:将引发可供性的语境与中性语境进行比较,不一致动词的N400显著降低,而一致动词的N400显著增强。我们将这些结果解释为语境触发的可供性被纳入名词意义的结果。将这些结果与对测试句子和语境之间语义相似性值的分析相结合,我们认为一种可能性是,可供性的纳入可以基于并发运动信息的心理模拟来解释。