Simon N, Verdoux H
Centre hospitalier Charles-Perrens, 121, rue de la Béchade, 33076 Bordeaux cedex, France.
Centre hospitalier Charles-Perrens, 121, rue de la Béchade, 33076 Bordeaux cedex, France; Université de Bordeaux, U657, 121, rue de la Béchade, 33000 Bordeaux, France; Inserm, U657, 33000 Bordeaux, France.
Encephale. 2018 Sep;44(4):329-336. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2017.05.003. Epub 2017 Jun 9.
The aim of the study was to explore whether a medical student education program and clinical posting in psychiatry had an impact on medical students' stigmatizing attitudes towards psychiatry and psychiatric disorders.
Medical students from the University of Bordeaux were recruited during their 4-year course at the beginning of the academic education program in psychiatry. Medical students who were concomitantly in a clinical posting in wards of psychiatry or neurology were invited to participate in the study. The medical student version of the scale Mental Illness: Clinicians' Attitudes (MICA) was used to measure their attitudes towards psychiatry and persons with psychiatric disorder. This 16-item scale is designed to measure attitudes of health care professionals towards people with mental illness, a higher score indicating more stigmatizing attitudes. Items exploring history of psychiatric disorders in close persons were added at the end of the MICA scale. The questionnaire was completed twice by each student, at the beginning and the end of the 11-week clinical posting. All questionnaires were strictly anonymized. Multivariate linear regression analyses were used to identify the variables independently associated with MICA total score.
At the beginning of the education program and clinical posting, 174 students completed the MICA scale: the mean MICA total score was equal to 46.4 (SD 6.9) in students in clinical posting in psychiatry (n=72) and 45.1 (SD 7.01) in those in neurology (n=102). At the end of the academic and clinical training, 138 students again completed the questionnaire, with mean MICA total scores equal to 41.4 (SD 8.1) in students in clinical posting in psychiatry (n=51) and 43.5 (SD 7.3) in those in neurology (n=87). Multivariate analyses showed that lower total MICA scores were independently associated with the time of assessment (lower scores at the end of education program and clinical posting) (b=-2.8; P=0.001), female gender (b=-1.8; P=0.03) and history of a psychiatric disorder in a close person (b=-1.92; P=0.02). Type of clinical posting (psychiatry vs. neurology) was not independently associated with MICA total scores (b=-0.02; P=0.98). A significant interaction was found between the variables "time of assessment" and "type of clinical posting" (P=0.05): stratified analyses showed that MICA total scores decreased significantly only when the clinical posting was in psychiatry (b=-4.66; P=0.001), with no significant change in medical students in neurology wards (b=-1.45; P=0.16).
Stigmatizing attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry and psychiatric disorders are reduced by an education program in psychiatry, with a positive impact more marked when the education program is concomitant to a clinical posting in psychiatry. As future health professionals in charge of persons with psychiatric disorders, medical students are key targets of actions aimed at reducing stigma towards mental health disorders. It is hence of great importance to promote clinical training in psychiatric wards during medical studies for all future practitioners, irrespective of their future specialty.
本研究旨在探讨医学生教育项目及精神科临床实习是否会对医学生对精神科及精神疾病的污名化态度产生影响。
在波尔多大学的医学生接受精神科医学教育项目之初,即在其4年课程学习期间招募学生。邀请同时在精神科或神经科病房进行临床实习的医学生参与研究。采用医学生版的《精神疾病:临床医生态度量表》(MICA)来测量他们对精神科及精神疾病患者的态度。该16项量表旨在测量医护人员对精神疾病患者的态度,得分越高表明污名化态度越严重。在MICA量表末尾增加了关于亲密关系中精神疾病病史的问题。每位学生在为期11周的临床实习开始和结束时各完成一次问卷。所有问卷均严格匿名。采用多元线性回归分析来确定与MICA总分独立相关的变量。
在教育项目和临床实习开始时,174名学生完成了MICA量表:精神科临床实习学生(n = 72)的MICA总分平均为46.4(标准差6.9),神经科临床实习学生(n = 102)的MICA总分平均为45.1(标准差7.01)。在学术和临床培训结束时,138名学生再次完成问卷,精神科临床实习学生(n = 51)的MICA总分平均为41.4(标准差8.1),神经科临床实习学生(n = 87)的MICA总分平均为43.5(标准差7.3)。多元分析显示,MICA总分降低与评估时间(教育项目和临床实习结束时得分较低)(b = -2.8;P = 0.001)、女性性别(b = -1.8;P = 0.03)以及亲密关系中有精神疾病病史(b = -1.92;P = 0.02)独立相关。临床实习类型(精神科与神经科)与MICA总分无独立相关性(b = -0.02;P = 0.98)。发现变量“评估时间”和“临床实习类型”之间存在显著交互作用(P = 0.05):分层分析表明,仅当临床实习在精神科时,MICA总分显著降低(b = -4.66;P = 0.001),而神经科病房的医学生无显著变化(b = -1.45;P = 0.16)。
精神科教育项目可降低医学生对精神科及精神疾病的污名化态度,当教育项目与精神科临床实习同时进行时,积极影响更为显著。作为未来负责精神疾病患者的健康专业人员,医学生是旨在减少对精神健康障碍污名化行动的关键目标人群。因此,对于所有未来的从业者,无论其未来专业如何,在医学学习期间促进精神科病房的临床培训非常重要。