Saini Ramswaroop, Singh Amit Kumar, Dhanapal Shanmuhapreya, Saeed Thoufeequl Hakeem, Hyde Geoffrey J, Baskar Ramamurthy
Department of Biotechnology, Indian Institute of Technology-Madras, Bhupat and Jyoti Mehta School of Biosciences, Chennai, 600 036, India.
Write about Research, 14 Randwick Street, Randwick, Sydney, 2031, Australia.
BMC Plant Biol. 2017 Jun 14;17(1):103. doi: 10.1186/s12870-017-1051-1.
Plants exposed to environmental stresses draw upon many genetic and epigenetic strategies, with the former sometimes modulated by the latter. This can help the plant, and its immediate progeny, at least, to better endure the stress. Some evidence has led to proposals that (epi) genetic changes can be both selective and sustainably heritable, while other evidence suggests that changes are effectively stochastic, and important only because they induce genetic variation. One type of stress with an arguably high level of stochasticity in its effects is temperature stress. Studies of how heat and cold affect the rates of meiotic recombination (MR) and somatic mutations (SMs, which are potentially heritable in plants) report increases, decreases, or no effect. Collectively, they do not point to any consistent patterns. Some of this variability, however, might arise from the stress being applied for such an extended time, typically days or weeks. Here, we adopted a targeted approach by (1) limiting exposure to one hour; and (2) timing it to coincide with (a) gamete, and early gametophyte, development, a period of high stress sensitivity; and (b) a late stage of vegetative development.
For plants (Arabidopsis thaliana) otherwise grown at 22 °C, we measured the effects of a 1 h exposure to cold (12 °C) or heat (32 °C) on the rates of MR, and four types of SMs (frameshift mutations; intrachromosomal recombination; base substitutions; transpositions) in the F1 progeny. One parent (wild type) was stressed, the other (unstressed) carried a genetic event detector. When rates were compared to those in progeny of control (both parents unstressed) two patterns emerged. In the progeny of younger plants (stressed at 36 days; pollinated at 40 days) heat and cold either had no effect (on MR) or (for SMs) had effects that were rare and stochastic. In the progeny of older plants (stressed at 41 days; pollinated at 45 days), while effects were also infrequent, those that were seen followed a consistent pattern: rates of all five genetic events were lowest at 12 °C and highest at 32 °C, i.e. they varied in a "dose-response" manner. This pattern was strongest (or, in the case of MR, only apparent) in progeny whose stressed parent was female.
While the infrequency of effects suggests the need for cautious inference, the consistency of responses in the progeny of older plants, indicate that in some circumstances the level of stochasticity in inherited genetic responses to heat or cold stress can be context-dependent, possibly reflecting life-cycle stages in the parental generation that are variably stress sensitive.
暴露于环境胁迫下的植物会采用多种遗传和表观遗传策略,前者有时会受到后者的调控。这至少有助于植物及其直接后代更好地耐受胁迫。一些证据表明(表观)遗传变化可能具有选择性且能稳定遗传,而其他证据则表明这些变化实际上是随机的,其重要性仅在于它们会诱导遗传变异。温度胁迫是一种其影响具有较高随机性的胁迫类型。关于热和冷如何影响减数分裂重组(MR)率和体细胞突变(SMs,在植物中可能是可遗传的)的研究报告了增加、减少或无影响的情况。总体而言,它们并未指向任何一致的模式。然而,这种变异性的一部分可能源于胁迫施加的时间过长,通常为数天或数周。在这里,我们采用了一种有针对性的方法,即(1)将暴露时间限制为1小时;(2)选择在(a)配子和早期配子体发育阶段(这是一个对胁迫高度敏感的时期)以及(b)营养发育后期进行胁迫处理。
对于原本在22°C下生长的植物(拟南芥),我们测量了1小时暴露于冷(12°C)或热(32°C)对F1后代中MR率以及四种类型的SMs(移码突变;染色体内重组;碱基替换;转座)的影响。一个亲本(野生型)受到胁迫,另一个(未受胁迫)携带一个遗传事件检测器。当将这些比率与对照后代(双亲均未受胁迫)的比率进行比较时,出现了两种模式。在较年轻植物的后代中(36天受到胁迫;40天授粉),热和冷要么没有影响(对MR),要么(对SMs)产生的影响罕见且随机。在较老植物的后代中(41天受到胁迫;45天授粉),虽然影响也不常见,但观察到的影响遵循一致的模式:所有五种遗传事件的发生率在12°C时最低,在32°C时最高,即它们以“剂量反应”方式变化。这种模式在受胁迫亲本为雌性的后代中最为明显(或者,就MR而言,仅为明显)。
虽然影响的罕见性表明需要谨慎推断,但较老植物后代中反应的一致性表明,在某些情况下,对热或冷胁迫的遗传反应中的随机性水平可能取决于具体情况,这可能反映了亲代中对胁迫敏感程度不同的生命周期阶段。