Lockwood Mark B, Saunders Milda R, Nass Rachel, McGivern Claire L, Cunningham Patrick N, Chon W James, Josephson Michelle A, Becker Yolanda T, Lee Christopher S
1 University of Illinois at Chicago College of Nursing, Department of Biobehavioral Science.
2 University of Chicago Medicine, Hospital Medicine and MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics.
Prog Transplant. 2017 Jun;27(2):131-138. doi: 10.1177/1526924817699957. Epub 2017 Mar 27.
Despite our knowledge of barriers to the early stages of the transplant process, we have limited insight into patient-reported barriers to the prekidney transplant medical evaluation in populations largely at-risk for evaluation failure.
One-hundred consecutive adults were enrolled at an urban, Midwestern transplant center. Demographic, clinical, and quality of life data were collected prior to patients visit with a transplant surgeon/nephrologist (evaluation begins). Patient-reported barriers to evaluation completion were collected using the Subjective Barriers Questionnaire 90-days after the initial medical evaluation appointment (evaluation ends), our center targeted goal for transplant work-up completion.
At 90 days, 40% of participants had not completed the transplant evaluation. Five barrier categories were created from the 85 responses to the Subjective Barriers Questionnaire. Patient-reported barriers included poor communication, physical health, socioeconomics, psychosocial influences, and access to care. In addition, determinants for successful evaluation completion included being of white race, higher income, free of dialysis, a lower comorbid burden, and reporting higher scores on the Kidney Disease Quality of Life subscale role-emotional.
Poor communication between patients and providers, and among providers, was the most prominent patient-reported barrier identified. Barriers were more prominent in marginalized groups such as ethnic minorities and people with low income. Understanding the prevalence of patient-reported barriers may aid in the development of patient-centered interventions to improve completion rates.
尽管我们了解移植过程早期阶段的障碍,但对于在很大程度上面临评估失败风险的人群中,患者报告的肾移植前医学评估障碍,我们的了解有限。
在中西部城市的一家移植中心连续招募了100名成年人。在患者拜访移植外科医生/肾病学家(评估开始)之前收集人口统计学、临床和生活质量数据。在初次医学评估预约90天后(评估结束),使用主观障碍问卷收集患者报告的评估完成障碍,这是我们中心移植检查完成的目标时间。
在90天时,40%的参与者尚未完成移植评估。从对主观障碍问卷的85份回复中创建了五个障碍类别。患者报告的障碍包括沟通不畅、身体健康、社会经济状况、心理社会影响和获得医疗服务的机会。此外,评估成功完成的决定因素包括白人种族、较高收入、未进行透析、较低的合并症负担以及在肾病生活质量子量表角色 - 情感方面得分较高。
患者与提供者之间以及提供者之间沟通不畅是所确定的最突出的患者报告障碍。这些障碍在少数民族和低收入人群等边缘化群体中更为突出。了解患者报告障碍的普遍性可能有助于制定以患者为中心的干预措施,以提高完成率。