Goh Joel C, Tan Jarrod K, Lim Janice W, Shridhar Iyer G, Madhavan Krishnakumar, Kow Alfred W
Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
Division of Hepatobiliary and Pancreatic Surgery and Liver Transplantation, Department of Surgery, National University Hospital, Singapore, Singapore.
Minerva Chir. 2017 Dec;72(6):455-463. doi: 10.23736/S0026-4733.17.07412-0. Epub 2017 Jun 16.
There is an increasing preference for early laparoscopic cholecystectomy (ELC) as compared to delayed LC (DLC) in the management of acute cholecystitis (AC). Conversion to open cholecystectomy (LOC) remains an important outcome. We aim to compare ELC and DLC outcomes and identify LOC predictors.
Retrospective analysis of 466 patients who underwent LC for AC from June 2010 to June 2015 was performed. Patients were divided into ELC and DLC groups, defined as LC performed within 7 days and between 4 to 24 weeks of symptom onset, respectively. Peri-operative outcomes and predictors for LOC were analyzed.
Conversion rates were comparable [ELC, 8.6% vs. DLC, 8.0%] (P=0.867). While median operative time was longer in ELC (101.5 min [83.0-130.1]) than DLC (88.0 min [62.3-118.8]) (P<0.001), intraoperative (ELC, 1.9% vs. DLC, 3.0%; P=0.541) and postoperative morbidity (ELC, 13.5% vs. DLC, 12.5%; P=0.688) was comparable. Median total length of stay (LOS) was shorter in ELC (4 days [3-6]) than DLC (5 days [4-9]) (P<0.001). Univariate analysis showed increased age (LC, 57 [45-66] vs. LOC, 60 [56-72]; P=0.016), presence of comorbidities (LC, 69.0% vs. LOC, 87.8%; P=0.009), previous abdominal surgery (LC, 6.1% vs. LOC, 17.1%; P=0.014), fever (P=0.001), Murphy's sign (P=0.005) and lower albumin (LC, 42.0 [39.0-45.0] vs. LOC, 40.0 [36.0-43.0]; P=0.003) to be predictors for LOC.
ELC provides shorter LOS and eliminates the risk of gallstone-related morbidity while awaiting surgery. It should be advocated for patients with AC. The presence of comorbidities, increased age, previous abdominal surgery and low albumin are predictors for conversion.
与延迟腹腔镜胆囊切除术(DLC)相比,急性胆囊炎(AC)的治疗中越来越倾向于早期腹腔镜胆囊切除术(ELC)。转为开腹胆囊切除术(LOC)仍是一个重要的结果。我们旨在比较ELC和DLC的结果并确定LOC的预测因素。
对2010年6月至2015年6月因AC接受LC的466例患者进行回顾性分析。患者分为ELC组和DLC组,分别定义为在症状出现后7天内和4至24周内进行的LC。分析围手术期结果和LOC的预测因素。
转化率相当[ELC为8.6%,DLC为8.0%](P = 0.867)。虽然ELC的中位手术时间(101.5分钟[83.0 - 130.1])比DLC(88.0分钟[62.3 - 118.8])长(P < 0.001),但术中(ELC为1.9%,DLC为3.0%;P = 0.541)和术后发病率(ELC为13.5%,DLC为12.5%;P = 0.688)相当。ELC的中位总住院时间(LOS)(4天[3 - 6])比DLC(5天[4 - 9])短(P < 0.001)。单因素分析显示,年龄增加(LC组为57岁[45 - 66],LOC组为60岁[56 - 72];P = 0.016)、合并症的存在(LC组为69.0%,LOC组为87.8%;P = 0.009)、既往腹部手术史(LC组为6.1%,LOC组为17.1%;P = 0.014)、发热(P = 0.001)、墨菲氏征(P = 0.005)和较低的白蛋白水平(LC组为42.0[39.0 - 45.0],LOC组为40.0[36.0 - 43.0];P = 0.003)是LOC的预测因素。
ELC可缩短LOS,并消除等待手术期间与胆结石相关的发病风险。对于AC患者应提倡采用。合并症的存在、年龄增加、既往腹部手术史和低白蛋白水平是转为开腹手术的预测因素。