Smith Kevin M, Gerrie Brayden J, McCulloch Patrick C, Lewis Brian D, Mather R Chad, Van Thiel Geoffrey, Nho Shane J, Harris Joshua D
Houston Methodist Orthopedics and Sports Medicine, 6550 Fannin Street, Smith Tower, Suite 2500, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University Medical Center, Box 2887, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
J Hip Preserv Surg. 2016 Dec 7;4(1):18-29. doi: 10.1093/jhps/hnw036. eCollection 2017 Jan.
To design and conduct a survey analyzing pre-, intra- and post- hip arthroscopy practice patterns among hip arthroscopists worldwide. A 21-question, IRB-exempt, HIPAA-compliant, cross-sectional survey was conducted via email using SurveyMonkey to examine pre-operative evaluation, intra-operative techniques and post-operative management. The survey was administered internationally to 151 hip arthroscopists identified from publicly available sources. Seventy-five respondents completed the survey (151 ± 116 hip arthroscopy procedures per year; 8.6 ± 7.1 years hip arthroscopy experience). Standing AP pelvis, false profile and Dunn 45 were the most common radiographs utilized. CT scans were utilized by 54% of surgeons at least some of the time. Only 56% of participants recommended an arthrogram with MRI. Nearly all surgeons either never (40%) or infrequently (58%) performed arthroscopy in Tönnis grade-2 or grade-3 osteoarthritis. Surgeons rarely performed hip arthroscopy on patients with dysplasia (51% never; 44% infrequently). Only 25% of participants perform a routine 'T' capsulotomy and 41% close the capsule if the patient is at risk for post-operative instability. Post-operatively, 52% never use a brace, 39% never use a continuous passive motion, 11% never recommended heterotopic ossification prophylaxis and 30% never recommended formal thromboembolic disease prophylaxis. Among a large number of high-volume experienced hip arthroscopists worldwide, pre-, intra- and post- hip arthroscopy practice patterns have been established and reported. Within this cohort of respondents, several areas of patient evaluation and management remain discordant and controversial without universal agreement. Future research should move beyond expert opinion level V evidence towards high-quality appropriately designed and conducted investigations.
设计并开展一项调查,分析全球髋关节镜医师在髋关节镜检查术前、术中和术后的操作模式。通过SurveyMonkey以电子邮件形式开展了一项包含21个问题、无需经机构审查委员会(IRB)批准且符合《健康保险流通与责任法案》(HIPAA)的横断面调查,以检查术前评估、术中技术和术后管理情况。该调查在国际范围内对从公开来源确定的151名髋关节镜医师进行。75名受访者完成了调查(每年平均进行151±116例髋关节镜手术;髋关节镜手术经验为8.6±7.1年)。站立位前后位骨盆片、假斜位片和邓恩45°位片是最常用的X线片。54%的外科医生至少在某些时候会使用CT扫描。只有56%的参与者建议进行关节造影并联合MRI检查。几乎所有外科医生在托尼斯2级或3级骨关节炎患者中要么从未(40%)进行过关节镜检查,要么很少(58%)进行。外科医生很少对发育不良患者进行髋关节镜检查(51%从未进行;44%很少进行)。只有25%的参与者常规进行“T”形关节囊切开术,41%在患者有术后不稳定风险时缝合关节囊。术后,52%的人从不使用支具,39%的人从不使用持续被动运动,11%的人从不建议预防异位骨化,30%的人从不建议进行正式的血栓栓塞性疾病预防。在全球众多经验丰富的高手术量髋关节镜医师中已确立并报告了髋关节镜检查术前、术中和术后的操作模式。在这组受访者中,患者评估和管理的几个方面仍然存在不一致和争议,未达成普遍共识。未来的研究应超越专家意见的V级证据,转向高质量的、设计和实施得当的调查研究。