Harper Daniel E, Shah Yash, Ichesco Eric, Gerstner Geoffrey E, Peltier Scott J
Chronic Pain and Fatigue Research Center, Department of Anesthesiology, School of Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Functional MRI Laboratory, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Pain Rep. 2016 Sep;1(3). doi: 10.1097/PR9.0000000000000572.
Central nervous system factors are now understood to be important in the etiology of temporomandibular disorders (TMD), but knowledge concerning objective markers of central pathophysiology in TMD is lacking. Multivariate analysis techniques like support vector machines (SVMs) could generate important discoveries regarding the expression of pain centralization in TMD. Support vector machines can recognize patterns in “training” data and subsequently classify or predict new “test” data. : We set out to detect the presence and location of experimental pressure pain and determine clinical status by applying SVMs to pain-evoked brain activity. Functional magnetic resonance imaging was used to record brain activity evoked by subjectively equated noxious temporalis pressures in patients with TMD and controls. First, we trained an SVM to recognize when the evoked pain stimulus was on or off based on each individual's pain-evoked blood–oxygen–level–dependent (BOLD) signals. Next, an SVM was trained to distinguish between the BOLD response to temporalis-evoked pain vs thumb-evoked pain. Finally, an SVM attempted to determine clinical status based on temporalis-evoked BOLD. The on-versus-off accuracy in controls and patients was 83.3% and 85.1%, respectively, both significantly better than chance (ie, 50%). Accurate determination of experimental pain location was possible in patients with TMD (75%), but not in healthy subjects (55%). The determination of clinical status with temporalis-evoked BOLD (60%) failed to reach statistical significance. The SVM accurately detected the presence of noxious temporalis pressure in patients with TMD despite the stimulus being colocalized with their ongoing clinical pain. The SVM's ability to determine the location of noxious pressure only in patients with TMD reveals somatotopic-dependent differences in central pain processing that could reflect regional variations in pain valuation.
目前认为中枢神经系统因素在颞下颌关节紊乱病(TMD)的病因中很重要,但缺乏关于TMD中枢病理生理学客观标志物的知识。像支持向量机(SVM)这样的多变量分析技术可能会在TMD疼痛集中化表达方面产生重要发现。支持向量机可以识别“训练”数据中的模式,随后对新的“测试”数据进行分类或预测。我们着手通过将支持向量机应用于疼痛诱发的大脑活动来检测实验性压力疼痛的存在和位置,并确定临床状态。功能磁共振成像用于记录TMD患者和对照组中由主观等效的颞肌有害压力诱发的大脑活动。首先,我们训练了一个支持向量机,根据每个人的疼痛诱发的血氧水平依赖(BOLD)信号来识别诱发疼痛刺激是开启还是关闭。接下来,训练一个支持向量机来区分对颞肌诱发疼痛与拇指诱发疼痛的BOLD反应。最后,一个支持向量机试图根据颞肌诱发的BOLD来确定临床状态。对照组和患者的开启与关闭准确率分别为83.3%和85.1%,均显著高于随机水平(即50%)。在TMD患者中能够准确确定实验性疼痛位置(75%),但在健康受试者中则不能(55%)。用颞肌诱发的BOLD确定临床状态(60%)未达到统计学意义。尽管刺激与他们正在经历的临床疼痛共定位,但支持向量机仍能准确检测出TMD患者中有害颞肌压力的存在。支持向量机仅在TMD患者中确定有害压力位置的能力揭示了中枢疼痛处理中躯体感觉依赖性差异,这可能反映了疼痛评估的区域差异。