Wentzel Dorien, Brysiewicz Petra
University of KwaZulu-Natal.
Oncol Nurs Forum. 2017 May 1;44(3):E124-E140. doi: 10.1188/17.ONF.E124-E140.
PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION: Oncology nurses are regularly exposed to high-stress situations that may lead to compassion fatigue, and many institutions have implemented interventions to reduce burnout in nurses, but knowledge on the feasiblity, effectiveness, and nurses' experience of interventions is lacking. .
LITERATURE SEARCH: Electronic search of literature published from 1992-2015 was performed to evaluate in-facility interventions to manage compassion fatigue in oncology nurses. Databases used included CINAHL®, PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and PsycINFO®. .
DATA EVALUATION: The goal was to evaluate the effectiveness, feasibility, and nurses' experience of interventions to manage compassion fatigue. The study designs, methods, and limitations were independently screened by the authors. .
SYNTHESIS: Of 164 studies, 31 met eligibility criteria. .
CONCLUSIONS: The majority of the studies were conducted in Western countries, which suggests the need for additional research in other settings to determine effective interventions that address compassion fatigue and stress cross-culturally. Quantitative and qualitative studies failed to gain high scores in terms of quality. Limited conclusions can be drawn from small studies that report on outcomes with many confounding variables, such as turnover rate or general health of nurses, from a single institution. .
Lack of empirical precision in evaluating the effectiveness, feasibility, and nurses' experiences of interventions indicates a need for future, more rigorously designed experimental studies. Because of the global increase in the number of patients being diagnosed and living with cancer, oncology nurses should be able to recognize and manage compassion fatigue.
肿瘤护理人员经常面临可能导致同情疲劳的高压力情况,许多机构已实施干预措施以减少护士的职业倦怠,但缺乏关于干预措施的可行性、有效性以及护士对这些干预措施体验的相关知识。
对1992年至2015年发表的文献进行电子检索,以评估机构内部针对肿瘤护理人员同情疲劳的干预措施。使用的数据库包括护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL®)、医学期刊数据库(PubMed)、科学引文索引数据库(Web of Science)、谷歌学术搜索以及心理学文摘数据库(PsycINFO®)。
目标是评估管理同情疲劳干预措施的有效性、可行性以及护士的体验。研究设计、方法和局限性由作者独立筛选。
164项研究中,31项符合纳入标准。
大多数研究在西方国家进行,这表明需要在其他环境中开展更多研究,以确定能够跨文化解决同情疲劳和压力问题的有效干预措施。定量和定性研究在质量方面未能获得高分。对于来自单一机构的、报告了许多混杂变量(如护士离职率或总体健康状况)结果的小型研究,只能得出有限的结论。
在评估干预措施的有效性、可行性以及护士体验方面缺乏实证精确性,这表明未来需要设计更严谨的实验研究。由于全球癌症诊断患者和癌症存活患者数量的增加,肿瘤护理人员应能够识别并管理同情疲劳。