Field J, Stone S, Orsini C, Hussain A, Vital S, Crothers A, Walmsley D
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
Newcastle University, Newcastle, UK.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2018 May;22(2):122-127. doi: 10.1111/eje.12276. Epub 2017 Jun 21.
Since 1981, the qualifications for various healthcare professionals across the European Union have enjoyed mutual recognition in accordance with the EU Directive 81/1057/EEC. Whilst the directive includes dental practitioners, it is recognised that significant variation exists in curriculum structure, content and scope of practice across institutions. This article aimed to explore pan-European practice in relation to curriculum content, teaching and learning strategies and assessment of pre-clinical dental skills.
A request to complete an online questionnaire, in English, was sent electronically to skills leads at all Association of Dental Education in Europe member schools. The questionnaire collected information in relation to institution and country, regulatory requirements to demonstrate safety, details of specific pre-clinical skills courses, learning materials and teaching staff.
Forty-eight institutions, from 25 European countries responded. Seven countries (n=7, 28%) reported no requirement to demonstrate student operative safety prior to patient treatment. Several core and operative clinical skills are common to the majority of institutions. The most commonly taught core skills related directly to the clinical environment such as cross-infection control and hand washing. The least common were skills that indirectly related to patient care, such as communication skills and working as a team.
There are clear differences within European pre-clinical dental education, and greater efforts are needed to demonstrate that all European students are fit to practice before they start treating patients. Learning outcomes, teaching activities and assessment activities of pre-clinical skills should be shared collaboratively to further standardise curricula.
自1981年以来,根据欧盟第81/1057/EEC号指令,欧盟各国各类医疗保健专业人员的资格得到了相互认可。虽然该指令涵盖牙科从业人员,但人们认识到,各机构在课程结构、内容和实践范围方面存在显著差异。本文旨在探讨欧洲范围内与课程内容、教学策略以及临床前牙科技能评估相关的实践情况。
以电子方式向欧洲牙科教育协会所有成员学校的技能负责人发送了一份用英文填写的在线调查问卷。该问卷收集了有关机构和国家、证明安全性的监管要求、特定临床前技能课程的详细信息、学习材料和教学人员的信息。
来自25个欧洲国家的48所机构做出了回应。7个国家(n = 7,28%)报告称,在患者治疗前无需证明学生的操作安全性。大多数机构都有一些核心和操作临床技能是共通的。最常教授的核心技能直接与临床环境相关,如交叉感染控制和洗手。最不常见的是与患者护理间接相关的技能,如沟通技能和团队协作。
欧洲临床前牙科教育存在明显差异,需要做出更大努力以证明所有欧洲学生在开始治疗患者之前都具备从业资格。临床前技能的学习成果、教学活动和评估活动应通过合作共享,以进一步规范课程。