Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Thomas Jefferson University.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, School of Medicine, Wayne State University.
Psychol Addict Behav. 2017 Dec;31(8):907-921. doi: 10.1037/adb0000291. Epub 2017 Jun 22.
Contingency management (CM) is an effective intervention for reducing use of licit and illicit substances in a variety of populations. Pregnant women are a vulnerable population with much to gain from effective interventions for substance use disorders, and for whom CM interventions may be especially well-suited. We reviewed the literature on CM interventions among pregnant women with tobacco and other substance use disorders with 3 aims: (a) describe the effectiveness of CM for reducing use of tobacco and other substances during pregnancy, (b) describe the effects of CM interventions on infant outcomes, and (c) identify needs for future research on CM in pregnancy. Our search strategy revealed 27 primary studies of CM in pregnancy. CM was effective in the majority of studies targeting nicotine abstinence, and results were mixed in studies targeting illicit substances. A variety of methodologies were used within the relatively small number of studies making it difficult to identify underlying mechanisms. Also, very few studies reported maternal and infant outcomes, and significant effects of CM were only apparent when secondary analyses pooled data from multiple studies. Furthermore, there is extremely limited data on the cost effectiveness of CM interventions in pregnancy. Future research should address these 3 areas to better determine the ultimate value of CM as an efficacious treatment for pregnant women with substance use disorders. (PsycINFO Database Record
应急管理(CM)是一种有效的干预措施,可减少各种人群中合法和非法物质的使用。孕妇是一个弱势群体,她们从有效的物质使用障碍干预措施中获益良多,而 CM 干预措施可能特别适合她们。我们回顾了针对有烟草和其他物质使用障碍的孕妇的 CM 干预措施的文献,有 3 个目的:(a)描述 CM 减少怀孕期间吸烟和其他物质使用的有效性,(b)描述 CM 干预措施对婴儿结局的影响,以及(c)确定 CM 在怀孕期间的未来研究需求。我们的搜索策略揭示了 27 项针对妊娠期间 CM 的主要研究。CM 在针对尼古丁戒断的大多数研究中是有效的,而在针对非法物质的研究中结果则不一。在为数不多的研究中使用了各种方法学,这使得难以确定潜在的机制。此外,很少有研究报告了母婴结局,并且只有在二次分析汇总多个研究的数据时,CM 的显著效果才显现出来。此外,关于 CM 干预措施在妊娠中的成本效益的数据极其有限。未来的研究应该解决这 3 个方面的问题,以更好地确定 CM 作为一种有效的治疗方法,对有物质使用障碍的孕妇的最终价值。