Zhao Wei, Jin Hong, Zhang Lili, Wang Bin, Sun Fangyuan, Jiao Huanli, Sun Chao, Wang Bangmao
Department of GI, Tianjin Medical University General Hospital, Tianjin 300054, China.
Physical Examination Center, Tianjin Medical University General Hospital, Tianjin 300054, China.
Gastroenterol Res Pract. 2017;2017:1214584. doi: 10.1155/2017/1214584. Epub 2017 Jun 1.
To explore whether pictograms could help people understand reflux symptoms.
Gastroenterologists ( = 28), non-GI physicians ( = 30), healthy people without medical education ( = 34), patients with gastrointestinal reflux disease (GERD) ( = 45), and general people ( = 100) were included. Pictograms denoting classic reflux symptoms (sour regurgitation, heartburn, retrosternal pain, and regurgitation) were created by the joint efforts of an artist and a gastroenterologist. The subjects were asked to tell the meaning of each card within 30 s.
Compared with the physicians, healthy people without medical education tended to make mistakes in the understanding of the terms of reflux symptoms. Among GERD patients, all the terms of reflux symptoms could be understood accurately. Compared with that of non-GI physicians, GI physician had a higher accuracy in the understanding of the term regurgitation ( < 0.05). Pictograms denoting reflux symptoms could be understood accurately in all four groups. A sample from the general population showed that the recognition of the pictogram was more accurate than the recognition of the terms.
Pictograms could help ordinary people who do not have medical education to understand reflux symptoms more accurately in China. Compared with abstract terms, pictograms could be useful for epidemiological studies and diagnosis of GERD in the community.
探讨象形图是否有助于人们理解反流症状。
纳入了28名胃肠病学家、30名非胃肠科医生、34名无医学教育背景的健康人、45名胃食管反流病(GERD)患者以及100名普通人群。表示典型反流症状(反酸、烧心、胸骨后疼痛和反流)的象形图由一名艺术家和一名胃肠病学家共同创作。要求受试者在30秒内说出每张卡片的含义。
与医生相比,无医学教育背景的健康人在理解反流症状术语方面更容易出错。在GERD患者中,所有反流症状术语都能被准确理解。与非胃肠科医生相比,胃肠科医生对“反流”一词的理解准确率更高(P<0.05)。在所有四组中,表示反流症状的象形图都能被准确理解。来自普通人群的一个样本显示,象形图的识别比术语的识别更准确。
在中国,象形图可以帮助没有医学教育背景的普通人更准确地理解反流症状。与抽象术语相比,象形图可能对社区中GERD的流行病学研究和诊断有用。