Michener Jamila D
Cornell University.
J Health Polit Policy Law. 2017 Oct;42(5):865-900. doi: 10.1215/03616878-3940468. Epub 2017 Jun 29.
The geographic concentration of disadvantage is a key mechanism of inequity. In the United States, the spatial patterning of disadvantage renders it more than the sum of its individual parts and disproportionately harms economically and racially marginalized Americans. This article focuses specifically on the political effects of Medicaid beneficiaries being concentrated in particular locales. After offering a framework for conceptualizing the community-wide consequences of such policy concentration, I analyze aggregate multiyear data to examine the effect of Medicaid density on county-level voter turnout and local organizational strength. I find that, as the proportion of county residents enrolled in Medicaid increases, the prevalence of civic and political membership associations declines and aggregate rates of voting decrease. These results suggest that, if grassroots political action is to be part of a strategy to achieve health equity, policy makers and local organizations must make efforts to counteract the sometimes demobilizing "place-based" political effects of "people-based" policies such as Medicaid.
劣势的地理集中是不平等的关键机制。在美国,劣势的空间格局使其影响超过了其各个部分的总和,并对经济和种族上处于边缘地位的美国人造成了不成比例的伤害。本文特别关注医疗补助受益人集中在特定地区所产生的政治影响。在提供了一个概念框架来理解此类政策集中对社区的影响之后,我分析了多年的汇总数据,以研究医疗补助密度对县级选民投票率和地方组织力量的影响。我发现,随着参加医疗补助的县居民比例增加,公民和政治成员协会的普及率下降,总体投票率也降低。这些结果表明,如果基层政治行动要成为实现健康公平战略的一部分,政策制定者和地方组织必须努力抵消诸如医疗补助等“以人为本”政策有时会产生的削弱“基于地点”的政治影响。