Waito Ashley A, Valenzano Teresa J, Peladeau-Pigeon Melanie, Steele Catriona M
Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, University Health Network, 550 University Avenue, 12th floor, Toronto, ON, M5G 2A2, Canada.
Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, University of Toronto, 500 University Avenue, Suite 160, Toronto, ON, M5G 1V7, Canada.
Dysphagia. 2017 Dec;32(6):734-747. doi: 10.1007/s00455-017-9819-x. Epub 2017 Jun 29.
Dysphagia in motor neuron diseases (MNDs) is highly complex, affecting all stages of swallowing and leading to impaired swallowing safety and efficiency. In order to explore the degree to which research is capturing the symptom of dysphagia in MND, we conducted a scoping review of the existing literature. The primary aims of this review were to identify common themes within the literature on dysphagia in MND, explore patterns and trends in research focus, and identify if any imbalances exist between the research themes related to dysphagia description and management. A comprehensive search strategy yielded 1690 unique articles for review. Following relevance screening, a total of 157 articles were included in the synthesis. Relevant data and keywords were extracted from each article and grouped into themes. Frequency estimates were calculated for each theme to identify trends across research literature. Swallowing impairment in MNDs is described in a variety of ways across current research. The most commonly reported theme was Aspiration/Penetration, mentioned in 73.2% of all included articles; a significant imbalance was identified between reports of swallowing safety and efficiency (p = 0.008). The most frequently reported theme related to dysphagia management was Enteral Nutrition, and very few studies have reported on the efficacy of Rehabilitation/Compensatory recommendations. It is suggested that researchers and clinicians remain mindful of imbalances and gaps in research, and aim to characterize dysphagia in MNDs in a comprehensive manner. Further research investigating discrete, measureable changes in swallowing pathophysiology would be beneficial to delineate the key factors contributing to impaired swallowing safety and efficiency.
运动神经元病(MND)中的吞咽困难非常复杂,会影响吞咽的各个阶段,并导致吞咽安全性和效率受损。为了探究研究在多大程度上捕捉到了MND中吞咽困难的症状,我们对现有文献进行了一项范围综述。本综述的主要目的是确定MND吞咽困难文献中的共同主题,探索研究重点的模式和趋势,并确定与吞咽困难描述和管理相关的研究主题之间是否存在任何不平衡。全面的检索策略产生了1690篇独特的文章以供综述。经过相关性筛选,共有157篇文章纳入综合分析。从每篇文章中提取相关数据和关键词,并将其分组为主题。计算每个主题的频率估计值,以确定研究文献中的趋势。目前的研究以多种方式描述了MND中的吞咽障碍。最常报道的主题是误吸/渗透,在所有纳入文章中有73.2%提到;在吞咽安全性和效率的报告之间发现了显著的不平衡(p = 0.008)。与吞咽困难管理相关的最常报道主题是肠内营养,很少有研究报道康复/代偿建议的疗效。建议研究人员和临床医生关注研究中的不平衡和差距,并旨在全面描述MND中的吞咽困难。进一步研究吞咽病理生理学中离散的、可测量的变化将有助于确定导致吞咽安全性和效率受损的关键因素。