Thomas D'Aunno, PhD, is Professor, New York University Wagner School of Public Service. E-mail:
Health Care Manage Rev. 2019 Apr/Jun;44(2):183-194. doi: 10.1097/HMR.0000000000000175.
Multistakeholder alliances that bring together diverse organizations to work on community-level health issues are playing an increasingly prominent role in the U.S. health care system. Yet, these alliances by their nature are fragile. In particular, low barriers to exit make alliances particularly vulnerable to disruption if key stakeholders leave. What factors are linked to the sustainability of alliances? One way to approach this question is to examine the perceptions of alliance participants, whose on-going involvement in alliances likely will matter much to their sustainability.
This study addresses the question: "Under what conditions do participants in alliances consider that their alliances are well positioned for the future, will perform well over time, and will be able to deal effectively with future challenges?"
We draw on cross-sectional survey data collected in the summer of 2015 from a total number of 638 participants in 15 alliances that participated in the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's Aligning Forces for Quality program.
Results from regression analyses indicate that alliance participants are more likely to view their alliances as sustainable when they (a) share a common vision, goals, and strategies for the alliance and (b) perceive that the alliance has performed effectively in the past.
Leaders of multistakeholder alliances may need to ensure that alliances are collective efforts that build success one step at a time: to the extent that participants believe they share a vision and strategies and have had some prior success working together, the more likely they are to view the alliance as sustainable.
多方利益相关者联盟将不同的组织聚集在一起,共同解决社区层面的健康问题,在美国医疗保健系统中发挥着越来越重要的作用。然而,这些联盟本质上是脆弱的。特别是,退出的门槛很低,如果主要利益相关者离开,联盟很容易受到干扰。有哪些因素与联盟的可持续性有关?一种方法是研究联盟参与者的看法,他们持续参与联盟对联盟的可持续性可能非常重要。
本研究探讨了以下问题:“在什么情况下,联盟参与者认为他们的联盟有良好的未来定位,将在未来表现良好,并能够有效应对未来的挑战?”
我们借鉴了 2015 年夏季从参与罗伯特伍德约翰逊基金会“Aligning Forces for Quality”计划的 15 个联盟中的 638 名参与者收集的横断面调查数据。
回归分析的结果表明,当联盟参与者(a)共享联盟的共同愿景、目标和战略,以及(b)认为联盟过去的表现有效时,他们更有可能将联盟视为可持续的。
多方利益相关者联盟的领导者可能需要确保联盟是集体努力,一步一个脚印地取得成功:在参与者认为他们共享愿景和战略并在共同工作方面取得了一些先前成功的情况下,他们更有可能将联盟视为可持续的。