Eijer Henk, Hogervorst Tom
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Spital Emmental, Switzerland.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Bergman Clinics, Rijswijk, Netherlands.
Med Hypotheses. 2017 Jul;104:93-96. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2017.05.035. Epub 2017 May 30.
Femoroacetabular impingement is the condition whereby parts of the proximal femur mechanically collide with the acetabular rim leading to adjacent and contrecoup acetabular damage. Evidence is growing that at least for cam impingement, and perhaps less so for pincer impingement, there is a relation to the development of osteoarthritis. It has been demonstrated that surgery for impingement can improve function and decrease pain. Intuitively, it would then make sense that surgical intervention would prevent further degeneration. However, available literature to date cannot assure that it does. Therefore, the impingement itself seems not a sufficient cause to consistently cause osteoarthritis. For many years we have observed a phenomenon whereby the femoral head 'migrates' anteriorly and superiorly in the acetabulum in patients with cam impingement. The same, but less constant, can be observed in pincer impingement, where the head may migrate posteriorly and medially. Migration of the femoral head is known in the literature and seen as caused by, or as part of, osteoarthritis of the hip. We suggest that the migration is caused by the impingement, and that the femoral head wanders into the impingement-related area with cartilage damage. In cam impingement this may be anterolateral, in pincer impingement posteromedial. The effect must be a huge increase in compression forces, especially in cam impingement. The migration may even lead to, or be a sign of, micro-instability of the femoral head in the acetabulum, which may produce an increase in shear forces. We therefore hypothesise that impingement may lead to osteoarthritis by means of migration and the possible existence of micro-instability of the femoral head. Detecting and quantifying these phenomena seem of uttermost importance and may add a new dimension to conservative hip surgery.
股骨髋臼撞击症是指股骨近端的部分结构与髋臼边缘发生机械性碰撞,导致髋臼相邻部位及对冲部位损伤的一种病症。越来越多的证据表明,至少对于凸轮撞击症而言,或许钳夹撞击症的关联性稍弱一些,其与骨关节炎的发展存在关联。已经证实,针对撞击症进行手术可以改善功能并减轻疼痛。直观地看,手术干预能够防止病情进一步恶化似乎是合理的。然而,迄今为止的现有文献无法确保确实如此。因此,撞击症本身似乎并非持续引发骨关节炎的充分原因。多年来,我们观察到一种现象,即在凸轮撞击症患者中,股骨头在髋臼内向前上方“移位”。在钳夹撞击症中也能观察到同样的现象,但不太常见,此时股骨头可能向后内侧移位。股骨头移位在文献中已有记载,被视为由髋关节骨关节炎引起或作为其一部分。我们认为这种移位是由撞击症导致的,并且股骨头会移至与撞击症相关且伴有软骨损伤的区域。在凸轮撞击症中,该区域可能位于前外侧,在钳夹撞击症中则位于后内侧。其结果必然是压缩力大幅增加,尤其是在凸轮撞击症中。这种移位甚至可能导致或预示着股骨头在髋臼内的微不稳定,进而可能使剪切力增加。因此,我们推测撞击症可能通过股骨头移位以及可能存在的微不稳定导致骨关节炎。检测和量化这些现象似乎至关重要,可能会为保守性髋关节手术增添新的维度。