Leiden University.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2017 Nov;29(11):1845-1859. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01162. Epub 2017 Jul 7.
Individual differences in attitudes to risk (a taste for risk, known probabilities) and ambiguity (a tolerance for uncertainty, unknown probabilities) differentially influence risky decision-making. However, it is not well understood whether risk and ambiguity are coded differently within individuals. Here, we tested whether individual differences in risk and ambiguity attitudes were reflected in distinct neural correlates during choice and outcome processing of risky and ambiguous gambles. To these ends, we developed a neuroimaging task in which participants ( n = 50) chose between a sure gain and a gamble, which was either risky or ambiguous, and presented decision outcomes (gains, no gains). From a separate task in which the amount, probability, and ambiguity level were varied, we estimated individuals' risk and ambiguity attitudes. Although there was pronounced neural overlap between risky and ambiguous gambling in a network typically related to decision-making under uncertainty, relatively more risk-seeking attitudes were associated with increased activation in valuation regions of the brain (medial and lateral OFC), whereas relatively more ambiguity-seeking attitudes were related to temporal cortex activation. In addition, although striatum activation was observed during reward processing irrespective of a prior risky or ambiguous gamble, reward processing after an ambiguous gamble resulted in enhanced dorsomedial PFC activation, possibly functioning as a general signal of uncertainty coding. These findings suggest that different neural mechanisms reflect individual differences in risk and ambiguity attitudes and that risk and ambiguity may impact overt risk-taking behavior in different ways.
个体对风险(风险偏好,已知概率)和不确定性(容忍不确定性,未知概率)的态度差异会对风险决策产生不同的影响。然而,人们并不清楚个体内部的风险和不确定性是否以不同的方式编码。在这里,我们测试了个体对风险和不确定性态度的差异是否反映在风险和不确定性赌博的选择和结果处理过程中的不同神经相关性中。为此,我们开发了一种神经影像学任务,其中参与者(n=50)在确定收益和赌博之间进行选择,赌博既有风险又有不确定性,并呈现决策结果(收益,没有收益)。从另一个任务中,我们可以估计个体的风险和不确定性态度,该任务中变化了金额、概率和不确定性水平。尽管在通常与不确定决策相关的网络中,风险和不确定性赌博之间存在明显的神经重叠,但相对而言,更倾向于冒险的态度与大脑(眶额内侧和眶额外侧)的估值区域的激活增加有关,而相对而言,更倾向于不确定性的态度与颞叶皮层的激活有关。此外,尽管在奖励处理过程中观察到纹状体激活,而不论之前的风险或不确定性赌博如何,但在进行不确定性赌博后,奖励处理会导致背内侧前额叶皮层的激活增强,这可能作为不确定性编码的一般信号。这些发现表明,不同的神经机制反映了个体对风险和不确定性态度的差异,并且风险和不确定性可能以不同的方式影响明显的冒险行为。