Anne Samantha, Juarez Jose Miguel, Shaffer Amber, Eleff David, Kitsko Dennis, Sydlowski Sarah, Woodson Erika, Chi David
Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2017 Aug;99:44-48. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2017.05.018. Epub 2017 May 26.
Routine plain film radiographs are often obtained to confirm proper placement of electrode after pediatric cochlear implant surgery. Objective is to evaluate necessity of routine radiographs in pediatric cochlear implant cases.
Retrospective review.
Two tertiary care academic centers.
Review of all children that underwent cochlear implantation from January 2003 thru June 2015. Exclusions include patients without intraoperative evoked compound action potential (ECAP) data or radiographs and patients undergoing revision surgeries.
235 pediatric patients underwent 371 cochlear implants. ECAP measurements were not available in two cases and were excluded from study. Radiographs were obtained in 35/369 cases due to intraoperative concern and four had abnormal findings. All four cases underwent change in management. One other patient had an x-ray because of difficult insertion and abnormal ECAP. Radiograph was normal; however, incision was opened and electrodes inserted further. Overall, 5/369 cases had changes in management intraoperatively. In all five cases, abnormalities were suspected by clinician judgment or abnormal ECAP measurements. Routine radiographs were completed in 349/369 cases and one was abnormal. This patient had known partial insertion due to cochlear fibrosis from meningitis and abnormal radiograph did not result in change in management.
Clinician suspicion and/or abnormal ECAP prompted suspicion for abnormal electrode placement prior to evaluation with radiograph in all cases in which change in management occurred. Intraoperative radiographs may be valuable in setting of clinical suspicion. Routine radiographs do not result in change in management and are, therefore, unnecessary.
小儿人工耳蜗植入术后常需进行常规X线平片检查以确认电极放置位置是否正确。本研究旨在评估小儿人工耳蜗植入病例中常规X线检查的必要性。
回顾性研究。
两个三级医疗学术中心。
回顾2003年1月至2015年6月期间所有接受人工耳蜗植入的儿童。排除标准包括术中未记录到诱发复合动作电位(ECAP)数据或未进行X线检查的患者以及接受翻修手术的患者。
235例小儿患者接受了371次人工耳蜗植入。2例患者未获得ECAP测量数据并被排除在研究之外。因术中担忧,369例中有35例进行了X线检查,其中4例有异常发现。所有4例均改变了治疗方案。另有1例患者因电极插入困难且ECAP异常而进行了X线检查。X线检查结果正常;然而,仍切开切口并进一步插入电极。总体而言,369例中有5例在术中改变了治疗方案。在所有5例中,临床医生通过判断或异常的ECAP测量怀疑存在异常情况。369例中有349例完成了常规X线检查,其中1例异常。该患者因脑膜炎导致耳蜗纤维化已知存在部分电极插入异常,而异常的X线检查结果并未导致治疗方案改变。
在所有治疗方案发生改变的病例中,临床医生的怀疑和/或异常的ECAP在进行X线检查评估之前提示怀疑电极放置异常。术中X线检查在临床怀疑的情况下可能有价值。常规X线检查不会导致治疗方案改变,因此是不必要的。