Wagner Mette Kirstine, Zwisler Ann-Dorthe Olsen, Risom Signe Stelling, Svendsen Jesper Hastrup, Christensen Anne Vinggaard, Berg Selina Kikkenborg
1 Department of Cardiology, The Heart Centre, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark.
2 Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark.
Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs. 2018 Feb;17(2):123-135. doi: 10.1177/1474515117720326. Epub 2017 Jul 12.
Increased physical capacity after comprehensive rehabilitation in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) undergoing ablation has been found in the CopenHeartRFA trial. The purpose of this study was to investigate: (a) sex differences in health status, psychological distress and quality of life, (b) sex differences in rehabilitation outcomes and (c) predictors of effect of rehabilitation.
We conducted an exploratory analysis of data from the randomized CopenHeartRFA trial, where patients treated with ablation were randomized with 1:1 to comprehensive rehabilitation consisting of a physical exercise program and psycho-educational consultations versus usual care. Sex disparities in health status were tested using Chi-square and t-tests.
Included were: 151 men (median age 59.25 years) and 59 women (median age 62.5 years). At hospital discharge, women reported lower physical health status compared with men. Among women, significant differences were found in the 6-min walk test [rehabilitation: 496.8 meters (SD 98.5) versus 559.3meters (SD 55.5) and usual care: 521.9 meters (SD 97.8) versus 530.9 meters (SD 102.2), p = 0.01] and exercise time [rehabilitation: 387.6 s (SD 126.0) versus 463.2 s (SD 121.8) and usual care: 353.4 s (SD 145.2) versus 355.8 s (SD 154.8), p < 0.004] and among men in the sit-to-stand test. Significant differences were found in mental health outcomes among men and in quality of life scores among women. Patients with a European Heart Rhythm Association (EHRA) score I-II had a positive effect of rehabilitation.
The results suggest that sex differences exist in self-reported health after rehabilitation in patients ablated for AF. Patients with an I-II EHRA score seem more likely to gain from the rehabilitation programme compared with those with a III-IV score.
在哥本哈根心脏射频消融试验(CopenHeartRFA trial)中发现,接受消融治疗的房颤(AF)患者在综合康复后体能增强。本研究的目的是调查:(a)健康状况、心理困扰和生活质量方面的性别差异;(b)康复结果的性别差异;(c)康复效果的预测因素。
我们对随机的哥本哈根心脏射频消融试验数据进行了探索性分析,在该试验中,接受消融治疗的患者按1:1随机分为接受包括体育锻炼计划和心理教育咨询的综合康复治疗组与常规治疗组。使用卡方检验和t检验来检测健康状况方面的性别差异。
纳入研究的有151名男性(中位年龄59.25岁)和59名女性(中位年龄62.5岁)。出院时,女性报告的身体健康状况低于男性。在女性中,6分钟步行试验[康复组:496.8米(标准差98.5)对559.3米(标准差55.5),常规治疗组:521.9米(标准差97.8)对530.9米(标准差102.2),p = 0.01]、运动时间[康复组:387.6秒(标准差126.0)对463.2秒(标准差121.8),常规治疗组:353.4秒(标准差145.2)对355.8秒(标准差154.8),p < 0.004]存在显著差异,在男性中坐立试验存在显著差异。男性的心理健康结果和女性的生活质量得分存在显著差异。欧洲心律协会(EHRA)评分I-II级的患者康复效果良好。
结果表明,接受房颤消融治疗的患者康复后自我报告的健康状况存在性别差异。与EHRA评分III-IV级的患者相比,I-II级评分的患者似乎更有可能从康复计划中获益。