Jolley Emma, Lynch Paul, Virendrakumar Bhavisha, Rowe Stacy, Schmidt Elena
a Research department , Sightsavers International , Haywards Heath , UK.
b Visual Impairment Centre for Teaching and Research , University of Birmingham , Birmingham , UK.
Disabil Rehabil. 2018 Nov;40(22):2704-2712. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2017.1353649. Epub 2017 Jul 14.
An estimated 1 billion people worldwide live with some form of disability. With the adoption of the Sustainable Development Goals and the "Leave no one behind" agenda, there is a global momentum to ensure that disadvantaged groups, not least people with disabilities, are included and accounted for, in mainstream development efforts. However, in many low-income settings little is known about disability and the policies and programs in place to improve the lives of those affected.
This literature review describes the extent and quality of published and unpublished literature on education and social inclusion of people with disabilities in five West African countries: Cameroon, Liberia, Mali, Sierra Leone and Senegal.
Fifty-four unique documents met inclusion criteria of the review and described related policy and legislation; national and international stakeholders; intervention programs and primary research related to disability and inclusion. The majority of documents were from Sierra Leone (19); and four described more than one country. Primary research included mainly qualitative studies and cross-sectional surveys; 33 sources were critically appraised with the majority being attributed unclear risk of bias (20).
The findings call for (i) standardized tools for monitoring the implementation of programs and policies at national level; (ii) improved stakeholder coordination mechanisms; (iii) development and adoption of coordinated approaches to measuring disability and social exclusion; (iv) rigorous evaluations of the effectiveness of disability programs and (v) disaggregation of routine data by disability. Implication for Rehabilitation There is a need for standardized tools for monitoring the implementation of programs and policies at national level. Countries that have not yet ratified the UNCRPD or the protocol should be supported to do so. Stakeholder coordination mechanisms need to be improved. Improved coordination between stakeholders involved in disability at the country level could help improve the quality of services delivered. Development and adoption of coordinated approaches is key to measuring disability and social exclusion. There are few, if any, rigorous evaluation of the effectiveness of disability-specific evaluations in the five countries. There is a need for disaggregation of routine data from development programs by disability to inform implementation.
全球估计有10亿人患有某种形式的残疾。随着可持续发展目标的通过以及“不让任何人掉队”议程的推进,全球形成了一股势头,以确保弱势群体,尤其是残疾人,被纳入主流发展努力并得到关注。然而,在许多低收入地区,人们对残疾情况以及为改善残疾人生活而制定的政策和项目知之甚少。
本文献综述描述了关于喀麦隆、利比里亚、马里、塞拉利昂和塞内加尔这五个西非国家残疾人教育与社会包容的已发表和未发表文献的范围与质量。
54份独特文件符合综述的纳入标准,描述了相关政策与立法、国家和国际利益相关者、干预项目以及与残疾和包容相关的初步研究。大多数文件来自塞拉利昂(19份);4份描述了不止一个国家的情况。初步研究主要包括定性研究和横断面调查;33份资料经过严格评估,大多数被认为存在不明确的偏倚风险(20份)。
研究结果呼吁(i)在国家层面采用标准化工具来监测项目和政策的实施情况;(ii)改进利益相关者协调机制;(iii)制定并采用协调一致的方法来衡量残疾情况和社会排斥;(iv)对残疾项目的有效性进行严格评估;(v)按残疾情况对常规数据进行分类。对康复的启示 需要在国家层面采用标准化工具来监测项目和政策的实施情况。应支持尚未批准《联合国残疾人权利公约》或其议定书的国家予以批准。利益相关者协调机制需要改进。改善国家层面参与残疾事务的利益相关者之间的协调有助于提高服务质量。制定并采用协调一致的方法是衡量残疾情况和社会排斥的关键。在这五个国家,针对特定残疾评估的有效性进行的严格评估极少,如果有的话。需要按残疾情况对发展项目的常规数据进行分类,以便为实施提供信息。