Asthma UK Centre for Applied Research, Usher Institute for Population Health Sciences and Informatics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
NHS Education for Scotland, Edinburgh, UK.
NPJ Prim Care Respir Med. 2017 Jul 18;27(1):45. doi: 10.1038/s41533-017-0041-y.
Despite an overwhelming evidence base, supported self-management of asthma is poorly implemented into routine practice. Strategies for implementation must address organisational routines, as well as provide resources for patients and training to improve professionals' skills. We aimed to explore the priority that primary care practices attach to asthma self-management, to describe their existing asthma management routines, and to generate innovative implementation strategies. We recruited 33 participants (23 general practitioners; seven nurses; three administrative staff) from 14 general practices. The 12 interviews and three focus groups were transcribed, coded and analysed thematically. Supported self-management was largely a nurse-led task within clinic-based annual reviews. Barriers included poor attendance at asthma clinics, lack of time, demarcation of roles, limited access to a range of tailored resources, and competing agendas in consultation, often due to multimorbidity. Suggestions for initiatives to improve the provision of supported self-management included emphasising the evidence for benefit (to influence prioritisation), improving teamwork (including team-based education), organisational strategies (including remote consulting) which need to fit within existing practice routines. Technology offers some potential solutions (e.g., improved templates, 'app'-based plans), but must be integrated with the practice information technology systems. Building on these insights, we will now develop a theoretically-based implementation strategy that will address patient, professional, and organisational buy-in, provide team-based education and offer a range of practical options and tools, which can be adapted and integrated within existing routines of individual practices.OVERCOMING THE ORGANISATIONAL BARRIERS TO IMPLEMENTING ASTHMA SELF-MANAGEMENT: Understanding the routines of primary care practices can suggest strategies to implement supported self-management in general practice. Supported self-management of asthma including provision of individual action plans improves patient health and reduces the burden on healthcare services, but is not well implemented in routine practice. As part of a large-scale programme to implement self-management into UK general practice, Hilary Pinnock at the University of Edinburgh and co-workers conducted interviews and focus groups with 33 participants from 14 general practices to explore the organisational routines that hinder or enable professionals to provide support asthma self-management. Poor attendance at asthma clinics, demarcation of roles, lack of time and limited access to tailored resources were identified as specific barriers. Improvements suggested included improved teamwork between doctors and other medical healthcare professionals, comprehensive training, and improvements to IT systems.
尽管有大量证据支持,但支持的哮喘自我管理在常规实践中实施得很差。实施策略必须解决组织常规问题,同时为患者提供资源并培训以提高专业人员的技能。我们旨在探讨基层医疗实践对哮喘自我管理的重视程度,描述其现有的哮喘管理常规,并制定创新的实施策略。我们从 14 个基层医疗实践中招募了 33 名参与者(23 名全科医生;7 名护士;3 名行政人员)。对 12 次访谈和 3 次焦点小组进行了转录、编码和主题分析。支持的自我管理主要是在以诊所为基础的年度审查中由护士主导的任务。障碍包括哮喘诊所出勤率低、时间有限、角色划分、有限的机会获得一系列量身定制的资源、以及咨询中经常因多病共存而产生的竞争议程。提高支持性自我管理提供的举措建议包括强调受益的证据(以影响优先级)、改善团队合作(包括团队为基础的教育)、组织策略(包括远程咨询),这些策略必须适应现有实践常规。技术提供了一些潜在的解决方案(例如,改进模板、基于应用程序的计划),但必须与实践信息技术系统集成。在此基础上,我们现在将制定一项基于理论的实施策略,该策略将解决患者、专业人员和组织的认同问题,提供团队为基础的教育,并提供一系列实用的选择和工具,这些工具可以在各个实践的现有常规中进行调整和整合。克服实施哮喘自我管理的组织障碍:了解基层医疗实践的常规可以为在基层医疗中实施支持性自我管理提供策略。支持的哮喘自我管理包括提供个人行动计划,可改善患者健康并减轻医疗服务负担,但在常规实践中实施不佳。作为在英国基层医疗中实施自我管理的大型计划的一部分,爱丁堡大学的希拉里·平诺克(Hilary Pinnock)和同事对来自 14 个基层医疗实践的 33 名参与者进行了访谈和焦点小组讨论,以探讨阻碍或使专业人员提供支持哮喘自我管理的组织常规。确定了出勤率低、角色划分、缺乏时间和获取量身定制资源有限等具体障碍。建议的改进包括改善医生和其他医疗保健专业人员之间的团队合作、全面培训和改进 IT 系统。