Bell Diane, Carl Arend, Swart Estelle
School of Business, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa.
Faculty of Education, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa.
Afr J Disabil. 2016 Sep 22;5(1):229. doi: 10.4102/ajod.v5i1.229. eCollection 2016.
A growing number of students with hearing loss are being granted access to higher education in South Africa due to the adoption of inclusive educational policies. However, available statistics indicate that participation by students with hearing impairments in higher education remains low and research suggests that support provisioning for those who do gain access is inadequate.
This article aims to illustrate that the assumed self-identity of students with hearing impairment influences their choice to disclose their disability. The choice not to disclose their hearing loss prevents them from accessing the necessary reasonable accommodations and this in turn may affect their eventual educational success.
Reported here is a qualitative descriptive case study at a South African university. Purposive sampling methods were employed. Data were gathered from in-depth interviews with seven students with hearing impairment ranging from moderate to profound, using spoken language. Constructivist grounded theory was used as an approach to the process of generating and transforming the data, as well as the construction of theory.
All the student participants identified as having a hearing rather than a D/deaf identity cultural paradigm and viewed themselves as 'normal'. Linked to this was their unwillingness to disclose their hearing impairment and thus access support.
It is crucially important for academic, support and administrative staff to be aware of both the assumed 'hearing' identity and therefore subsequent non-disclosure practices of students with a hearing impairment using the oral method of communication. Universities need to put measures in place to encourage students to voluntarily disclose their hearing impairment in order to provide more targeted teaching and learning support. This could lead to improved educational outcomes for students.
由于南非采用了包容性教育政策,越来越多有听力损失的学生获得了接受高等教育的机会。然而,现有统计数据表明,有听力障碍的学生在高等教育中的参与率仍然较低,而且研究表明,为那些获得入学机会的学生提供的支持不足。
本文旨在说明,有听力障碍的学生所假定的自我身份会影响他们披露自身残疾情况的选择。不披露听力损失的选择使他们无法获得必要的合理便利,这反过来可能会影响他们最终的学业成就。
本文报道了在南非一所大学进行的一项定性描述性案例研究。采用了目的抽样方法。通过对七名听力障碍程度从中度到重度的学生进行口语深度访谈来收集数据。建构主义扎根理论被用作生成和转换数据以及构建理论过程的一种方法。
所有参与研究的学生都认同听力而非聋人身份的文化范式,并认为自己“正常”。与此相关的是,他们不愿意披露自己的听力障碍,从而无法获得支持。
学术、支持和行政人员必须意识到有听力障碍的学生采用口语交流方式时所假定的“听力”身份以及随之而来的不披露行为。大学需要采取措施鼓励学生自愿披露自己的听力障碍,以便提供更有针对性的教学和学习支持。这可能会改善学生的教育成果。