Sekoto Lieketseng V, Hlayisi Vera-Genevey
Division of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Afr J Disabil. 2023 May 2;12:1168. doi: 10.4102/ajod.v12i0.1168. eCollection 2023.
Identity construction is an integral developmental task for adolescents and young adults (AYA). The intersection of deaf identity and disabling hearing loss (DHL) adds a layer to the complex process of identity construction.
This literature review highlights the self-ascribed deaf identities of AYA and seeks to understand how AYA with DHL forge these identities. Knowledge areas for prospective research and practice are uncovered.
A traditional literature review of qualitative empirical evidence on AYA's accounts of their deaf identity construction was conducted on seminal literature and peer-reviewed journals in psychology, disability studies and deaf studies.
The emerging self-ascribed deaf identities of AYA are diverse. The identities include Deaf, hearing, hard-of-hearing (HOH), bicultural HOH, identities that detach from disability, bicultural DeaF, unresolved and fluid identities. Complex trade-offs exist where the construction of certain identities forgoes certain reasonable accommodations, interventions or relations that are critical for personal development and wellbeing.
Current literature orients deaf identity formation around hearing status and Deaf-hearing communal dynamics. In-depth research comprising facets of AYA's personal, enacted and relational identities is required to conscientise rehabilitation professionals about the nuances of deaf identity issues and how to develop interventions that are supportive and responsive to the clinical and psychosocial challenges of AYA with DHL.
This paper deviates from the d/Deaf identity dichotomy, revealing a spectrum of deaf identities that AYA forge. The rationales of AYA's deaf identities, underlying processes and possible vulnerable identities are unpacked. Recommendations for prospective research pertaining to identity construction among deaf AYA are made.
身份认同构建是青少年和青年(AYA)一项不可或缺的发展任务。聋人身份与致残性听力损失(DHL)的交叉为身份认同构建这一复杂过程增添了一个层面。
本综述强调AYA自我认定的聋人身份,并试图了解患有DHL的AYA如何塑造这些身份。揭示了未来研究和实践的知识领域。
对心理学、残疾研究和聋人研究领域的经典文献和同行评审期刊进行传统文献综述,以获取关于AYA对其聋人身份认同构建描述的定性实证证据。
AYA新出现的自我认定的聋人身份多种多样。这些身份包括聋人、听力正常者、重听(HOH)、双文化重听、与残疾脱离的身份、双文化聋人、未解决的和流动的身份。在构建某些身份时,存在复杂的权衡,即放弃了对个人发展和幸福至关重要的某些合理便利、干预或关系。
当前文献围绕听力状况和聋人与听力正常者的群体动态来界定聋人身份形成。需要开展深入研究,涵盖AYA个人身份、实际身份和关系身份的各个方面,以使康复专业人员认识到聋人身份问题的细微差别,以及如何制定对患有DHL的AYA的临床和心理社会挑战具有支持性和响应性的干预措施。
本文偏离了聋人身份的二分法,揭示了AYA塑造的一系列聋人身份。剖析了AYA聋人身份的基本原理、潜在过程和可能的易受影响身份。针对聋人AYA身份认同构建的未来研究提出了建议。