New York University School of Medicine, New York, New York; and
Bellevue Hospital Center, New York, New York.
Pediatrics. 2017 Aug;140(2). doi: 10.1542/peds.2016-4165.
Parents often manage complex instructions when their children are discharged from the inpatient setting or emergency department (ED); misunderstanding instructions can put children at risk for adverse outcomes. Parents' ability to manage discharge instructions has not been examined before in a systematic review.
To perform a systematic review of the literature related to parental management (knowledge and execution) of inpatient and ED discharge instructions.
We consulted PubMed/Medline, Embase, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, and Cochrane CENTRAL (from database inception to January 1, 2017).
We selected experimental or observational studies in the inpatient or ED settings in which parental knowledge or execution of discharge instructions were evaluated.
Two authors independently screened potential studies for inclusion and extracted data from eligible articles by using a structured form.
Sixty-four studies met inclusion criteria; most ( = 48) were ED studies. Medication dosing and adherence errors were common; knowledge of medication side effects was understudied ( = 1). Parents frequently missed follow-up appointments and misunderstood return precaution instructions. Few researchers conducted studies that assessed management of instructions related to diagnosis ( = 3), restrictions ( = 2), or equipment ( = 1). Complex discharge plans (eg, multiple medicines or appointments), limited English proficiency, and public or no insurance were associated with errors. Few researchers conducted studies that evaluated the role of parent health literacy (ED, = 5; inpatient, = 0).
The studies were primarily observational in nature.
Parents frequently make errors related to knowledge and execution of inpatient and ED discharge instructions. Researchers in the future should assess parental management of instructions for domains that are less well studied and focus on the design of interventions to improve discharge plan management.
当孩子从住院病房或急诊部门(ED)出院时,父母通常需要管理复杂的医嘱;如果对医嘱理解有误,可能会使孩子面临不良后果的风险。目前,尚未有系统评价对父母管理住院和 ED 出院医嘱的能力进行研究。
对与父母管理(知识和执行)住院和 ED 出院医嘱相关的文献进行系统评价。
我们检索了 PubMed/Medline、Embase、护理学和联合健康文献累积索引以及 Cochrane 中心(从数据库建立至 2017 年 1 月 1 日)。
我们选择了在住院或 ED 环境中评估父母对出院医嘱的知识或执行情况的实验或观察性研究。
两位作者独立筛选潜在的纳入研究,并使用结构化表格从合格文章中提取数据。
64 项研究符合纳入标准;其中大多数(=48 项)为 ED 研究。药物剂量和用药依从性错误很常见;对药物副作用的了解研究不足(=1 项)。父母经常错过随访预约,对返回预防措施的医嘱理解有误。很少有研究评估与诊断(=3 项)、限制(=2 项)或设备(=1 项)相关的医嘱管理。复杂的出院计划(如,多种药物或预约)、英语水平有限、公共保险或无保险与错误相关。很少有研究评估父母健康素养(ED,=5 项;住院,=0 项)在医嘱管理中的作用。
这些研究主要是观察性研究。
父母在管理住院和 ED 出院医嘱的知识和执行方面经常出现错误。未来的研究人员应评估父母对研究较少的医嘱领域的管理情况,并专注于设计干预措施以改善出院计划管理。