Veenman Betty, Luman Marjolein, Oosterlaan Jaap
Clinical Neuropsychology Section, Faculty of Behavioural and Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamAmsterdam, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2017 Jul 11;8:1157. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01157. eCollection 2017.
The Positivity and Rules program (PR program), a low-level behavioral teacher program targeting symptoms of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), has shown positive effects on teacher-rated ADHD symptoms and social functioning. This study aimed to assess whether program effects could be confirmed by instruments assessing classroom behavior other than teacher-ratings, given teachers' involvement with the training. Participants were 114 primary school children (age = 6-13) displaying ADHD symptoms in the classroom, who were randomly assigned to the treatment ( = 58) or control group ( = 65). ADHD symptoms were measured using classroom observations and actigraphy, and peer acceptance was measured using peer ratings. Intention-to-treat multilevel analyses were conducted to assess program effects. No beneficial program effects were found for any of the measures. The earlier beneficial program effects on both ADHD symptoms and social functioning reported by teachers, may be explained by a change in the perception of teachers rather than changes in the child's behavior. Other methodological explanations are also discussed, such as differences between instruments in the sensitivity to program-related changes. The current study underlines the importance of using different measures of classroom behavior to study program effects. NCT02518711.
积极与规则计划(PR计划)是一项针对注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)症状的低层次行为教师计划,已显示出对教师评定的ADHD症状和社交功能有积极影响。鉴于教师参与了培训,本研究旨在评估除教师评定外,通过评估课堂行为的工具能否证实该计划的效果。参与者为114名在课堂上表现出ADHD症状的小学生(年龄6 - 13岁),他们被随机分配到治疗组(n = 58)或对照组(n = 65)。使用课堂观察和活动记录仪测量ADHD症状,使用同伴评定测量同伴接纳度。进行意向性治疗多层次分析以评估计划效果。未发现该计划对任何测量指标有有益影响。教师之前报告的该计划对ADHD症状和社交功能的有益影响,可能是由于教师认知的改变而非孩子行为的改变。还讨论了其他方法学解释,例如不同工具对与计划相关变化的敏感度差异。本研究强调了使用不同的课堂行为测量方法来研究计划效果的重要性。临床试验注册号:NCT02518711。