Fukuhara Takahiro, Donishi Ryohei, Matsuda Eriko, Koyama Satoshi, Fujiwara Kazunori, Takeuchi Hiromi
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Tottori University Faculty of Medicine, 36-1 Nishicho, Yonago, 683-8504, Japan.
World J Surg. 2018 Jan;42(1):130-136. doi: 10.1007/s00268-017-4151-z.
Ultrasonography is a non-invasive technique that is commonly used by endocrinologists and endocrine surgeons to examine the thyroid region and could be useful for the assessment of vocal cord movement by these specialists. However, previous studies reported a low rate of successful visualization of vocal cord movement by ultrasonography. To address this issue, we devised a novel ultrasonographic procedure for assessing vocal cord movement indirectly by observing the arytenoid movement from a lateral view.
Subjects were 188 individuals, including 23 patients with vocal cord paralysis and 13 with vocal cord paresis. We performed ultrasonographic assessment of vocal cord movement using two different procedures: the conventional middle transverse procedure and the novel lateral vertical procedure.
The rate of visualization of vocal cords with the middle transverse procedure was 70.2% and that of the arytenoid cartilage with the lateral vertical procedure was 98.4%. The lateral vertical procedure enabled visualization of all patients with vocal cord paresis/paralysis and detected all 23 patients with vocal paralysis; only one of 13 patients with vocal cord paresis was positively identified. The conventional procedure enabled visualization of 21 of 36 patients with vocal cord paresis/paralysis with high accuracy. There was no false-positive case in either procedure.
The proposed lateral vertical procedure improved the rate of visualization of vocal cord movement by ultrasonography, suggesting that it is a useful technique to screen for vocal cord paralysis by ultrasonography.
超声检查是一种非侵入性技术,内分泌科医生和内分泌外科医生常用其检查甲状腺区域,对这些专科医生评估声带运动可能有用。然而,既往研究报道超声检查时声带运动的成功可视化率较低。为解决这一问题,我们设计了一种新的超声检查方法,通过从侧面观察杓状软骨运动间接评估声带运动。
研究对象为188名个体,包括23例声带麻痹患者和13例声带轻瘫患者。我们采用两种不同方法对声带运动进行超声检查评估:传统的中间横向检查法和新的侧面纵向检查法。
中间横向检查法时声带的可视化率为70.2%,侧面纵向检查法时杓状软骨的可视化率为98.4%。侧面纵向检查法能使所有声带轻瘫/麻痹患者实现可视化,并检测出所有23例声带麻痹患者;13例声带轻瘫患者中仅1例被明确诊断。传统检查法能高精度地使36例声带轻瘫/麻痹患者中的21例实现可视化。两种检查法均未出现假阳性病例。
所提出的侧面纵向检查法提高了超声检查时声带运动的可视化率,表明它是一种通过超声检查筛查声带麻痹的有用技术。