Department of Urology, Careggi Hospital, University of Florence, Florence, Italy.
Department of Urology, Hospital Policlinico Tor Vergata, University of Roma Tor Vergata, Roma, Italy.
Eur Urol Focus. 2018 Mar;4(2):280-287. doi: 10.1016/j.euf.2016.06.006. Epub 2016 Jun 21.
Numerous surveys have been performed to determine the competence and the confidence of residents. However, there is no data available on the condition of Italian residents in urology.
To investigate the status of training among Italian residents in urology regarding scientific activity and surgical exposure.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A web-based survey that included 445 residents from all of the 25 Italian Residency Programmes was conducted between September 2015 and November 2015.
The main outcomes were represented by scientific activity, involvement in surgical procedures, and overall satisfaction.
In total, 324 out of 445 (72.8%) residents completed the survey. Overall, 104 (32%) residents had not published any scientific manuscripts, 148 (46%) published ≤5, 38 (12%) ≤10, 26 (8%) ≤15, four (1%) ≤20, and four (1%) >20 manuscripts, respectively. We did not observe any differences when residents were stratified by sex (p=0.5). Stent positioning (45.7%), extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (30.9%), transurethral resection of bladder tumor (33.0%), hydrocelectomy (24.7%), varicocelectomy (17%), ureterolithotripsy (14.5%), and orchiectomy (12.3%) were the surgical procedures more frequently performed by residents. Overall, 272 residents (84%) expressed a good satisfaction for urology specialty, while 178 (54.9%) expressed a good satisfaction for their own residency programme. We observed a statistically decreased trend for good satisfaction for urology specialty according to the postgraduate year (p=0.02).
Italian Urology Residency Programmes feature some heavy limitations regarding scientific activity and surgical exposure. Nonetheless, satisfaction rate for urology specialty remains high. Further improvements in Residency Programmes should be made in order to align our schools to others that are actually more challenging.
In this web-based survey, Italian residents in urology showed limited scientific productivity and low involvement in surgical procedures. Satisfaction for urology specialty remains high, demonstrating continuous interest in this field of study from residents.
已经进行了许多调查来确定住院医师的能力和信心。然而,目前还没有关于意大利泌尿科住院医师状况的数据。
调查意大利泌尿科住院医师在科研活动和手术经验方面的培训状况。
设计、地点和参与者:2015 年 9 月至 11 月期间,对来自意大利 25 个住院医师培训计划的 445 名住院医师进行了一项基于网络的调查。
主要结果为科研活动、手术参与度和总体满意度。
共有 324 名(72.8%)住院医师完成了调查。总的来说,有 104 名(32%)住院医师没有发表过任何科学论文,148 名(46%)发表了≤5 篇,38 名(12%)发表了≤10 篇,26 名(8%)发表了≤15 篇,4 名(1%)发表了≤20 篇,4 名(1%)发表了>20 篇论文。当按性别对住院医师进行分层时,我们没有观察到任何差异(p=0.5)。支架置入术(45.7%)、体外冲击波碎石术(30.9%)、经尿道膀胱肿瘤切除术(33.0%)、经皮肾造瘘术(24.7%)、精索静脉结扎术(17%)、输尿管镜碎石术(14.5%)和睾丸切除术(12.3%)是住院医师更常进行的手术。总的来说,272 名(84%)住院医师对泌尿科专业表示满意,178 名(54.9%)对自己的住院医师培训计划表示满意。我们观察到,随着研究生年级的增加,对泌尿科专业的满意度呈统计学下降趋势(p=0.02)。
意大利泌尿科住院医师培训计划在科研活动和手术经验方面存在一些严重的局限性。尽管如此,对泌尿科专业的满意度仍然很高。为了使我们的培训计划与其他更具挑战性的培训计划保持一致,应该对培训计划进行进一步的改进。
在这项基于网络的调查中,意大利泌尿科住院医师的科研成果有限,手术参与度低。对泌尿科专业的满意度仍然很高,这表明住院医师对该研究领域的持续兴趣。