Zemlan F P, Hirschowitz J, Sautter F, Garver D L
Psychiatry Res. 1986 Jul;18(3):239-55. doi: 10.1016/0165-1781(86)90111-3.
The authors propose an alternative model for relating clinically rated psychotic symptoms to biological measures in schizophrenic patients. They suggest that clinical presentation in schizophrenic patients comprises at least four distinct psychotic symptom clusters and that at most one or two of the symptom clusters are closely associated with central dopamine (DA) activity as measured by growth hormone (GH) response to apomorphine. Factor and cluster analytic techniques both identified the same four psychotic symptom clusters, three of which were similar to the major subtypes of schizophrenia: paranoid delusions (paranoid type), thought disorder (disorganized type), and catatonia (catatonic type). The fourth psychotic symptom cluster was auditory hallucinations, a prominent clinical feature of schizophrenia. The authors compared clinical symptom cluster scores to apomorphine-induced GH response by creating a new data set containing the output of the factor analysis of each patient's symptoms and GH response, and performing regression modeling of the patient's symptom cluster scores on GH response. Patients with elevated thought disorder cluster scores also had elevated GH responses to apomorphine, suggesting an association between thought disorder and central DA receptor supersensitivity. A fixed-dose neuroleptic trial showed that thought disorder and auditory hallucinations respond rapidly to treatment with a DA receptor blocker (haloperidol), while no significant effect on other symptom cluster scores occurred during the initial 2 weeks of treatment. These data suggest that two of the identified symptom clusters, thought disorder and auditory hallucinations, may be preferentially associated with central DA hyperactivity.
作者们提出了一种将精神分裂症患者临床评定的精神病性症状与生物学指标相关联的替代模型。他们认为,精神分裂症患者的临床表现至少包括四个不同的精神病性症状群,并且在通过对阿扑吗啡的生长激素(GH)反应所测量的中枢多巴胺(DA)活动中,最多有一到两个症状群与之密切相关。因子分析和聚类分析技术均识别出相同的四个精神病性症状群,其中三个与精神分裂症的主要亚型相似:偏执妄想(偏执型)、思维障碍(紊乱型)和紧张症(紧张型)。第四个精神病性症状群是幻听,这是精神分裂症的一个突出临床特征。作者通过创建一个新的数据集来比较临床症状群评分与阿扑吗啡诱导的GH反应,该数据集包含每个患者症状和GH反应的因子分析输出,并对患者症状群评分与GH反应进行回归建模。思维障碍群评分升高的患者对阿扑吗啡的GH反应也升高,这表明思维障碍与中枢DA受体超敏之间存在关联。一项固定剂量抗精神病药物试验表明,思维障碍和幻听对DA受体阻滞剂(氟哌啶醇)治疗反应迅速,而在治疗的最初2周内对其他症状群评分没有显著影响。这些数据表明,所识别的两个症状群,即思维障碍和幻听,可能与中枢DA活动亢进优先相关。