Carroll Allison J, Howrey Hillary L, Payvar Susan, Deshida-Such Kristen, Kansal Mayank, Brar Charanjit K
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL.
Siteman Cancer Center/Barnes-Jewish Hospital, St. Louis, MO.
Fed Pract. 2017 Apr;34(4):14-19.
Disease management programs for heart failure (HF) effectively reduce HF-related hospitalization rates and mortality. Shared medical appointments (SMAs) offer a cost-effective delivery method for HF disease management programs. However, few studies have evaluated this cost-effective delivery method of HF disease management among Veterans with acute HF. We hypothesized that Veterans who attended a multidisciplinary HF-SMA clinic promoting HF self-management, compared those who only received individual treatment through the HF specialty clinic, would have better 12-month hospitalization outcomes.
We completed a retrospective review of the VA electronic health record for HF-SMA clinic appointments (1/1/2012 to 12/31/2013). The multidisciplinary HF-SMA program comprised 4 weekly sessions covering topics including HF disease, HF medications, diet adherence, physical activity, psychological well-being, and stress management. Patients who attended the HF-SMA clinic (=54) were compared to patients who were scheduled for an HF-SMA appointment but never attended and were followed only in the HF clinic (=37). Outcomes were 12-month HF-related and all-cause hospitalization rates, days in the hospital, and time to first hospitalization.
Of 141 patients scheduled for an HF-SMA clinic appointment, 54 met criteria for the HF-SMA clinic group and 37 were included in the HF clinic group. The groups did not significantly differ on any sociodemographic variables. Furthermore, no significant differences were observed between the HF-SMA group and the HF clinic group on demographics or hospitalization outcomes, >.05 for all comparisons.
Our results did not support our hypothesis that offering multidisciplinary, HF-SMAs promoting HF self-management skills, above and beyond the individual disease management care provided in an HF specialty clinic, would improve hospitalization outcomes among Veterans with acute HF. Limitations of the present study and recommendations for HF self-management programs for Veterans are discussed.
心力衰竭(HF)疾病管理项目能有效降低与HF相关的住院率和死亡率。共享医疗预约(SMA)为HF疾病管理项目提供了一种具有成本效益的实施方式。然而,很少有研究评估这种针对急性HF退伍军人的具有成本效益的HF疾病管理实施方式。我们假设,与仅通过HF专科诊所接受个体治疗的退伍军人相比,参加多学科HF-SMA诊所以促进HF自我管理的退伍军人会有更好的12个月住院结局。
我们对VA电子健康记录中HF-SMA诊所预约情况(2012年1月1日至2013年12月31日)进行了回顾性分析。多学科HF-SMA项目包括4次每周一次的课程,涵盖的主题有HF疾病、HF药物、饮食依从性、身体活动、心理健康和压力管理。将参加HF-SMA诊所的患者(n = 54)与安排了HF-SMA预约但从未参加且仅在HF诊所接受随访的患者(n = 37)进行比较。结局指标为12个月与HF相关的住院率和全因住院率、住院天数以及首次住院时间。
在141名安排了HF-SMA诊所预约的患者中,54名符合HF-SMA诊所组标准,37名被纳入HF诊所组。两组在任何社会人口统计学变量上均无显著差异。此外,HF-SMA组和HF诊所组在人口统计学或住院结局方面也未观察到显著差异,所有比较的P值均>.05。
我们的结果不支持我们的假设,即提供多学科的、促进HF自我管理技能的HF-SMA,除了HF专科诊所提供的个体疾病管理护理之外,会改善急性HF退伍军人的住院结局。讨论了本研究的局限性以及对退伍军人HF自我管理项目的建议。