Gordon Ethel-Sherry, Haklai Ziona, Meron Jill, Aburbeh Miriam, Salz Inbal Weiss, Applbaum Yael, Goldberger Nehama F
Division of Health Information, Ministry of Health, Yirmiyahu, 39, 9446724, Jerusalem, Israel.
Isr J Health Policy Res. 2017 Aug 1;6(1):39. doi: 10.1186/s13584-017-0164-1.
Regional variations in mortality can be used to study and assess differences in disease prevalence and factors leading to disease and mortality from different causes. To enable this comparison, it is important to standardize the mortality data to adjust for the effects of regional population differences in age, nationality and country of origin.
Standardized mortality ratios (SMR) were calculated for the districts and sub-districts in Israel, for total mortality by gender as well as for leading causes of death and selected specific causes. Correlations were assessed between these SMRs, regional disease risk factors and socio-economic characteristics. Implications for health policy were then examined.
Total mortality in the Northern District of Israel was not significantly different from the national average; but the Haifa, Tel Aviv, and Southern districts were significantly higher and the Jerusalem, Central, Judea and Samaria districts were lower. Cancer SMR was significantly lower in Jerusalem and not significantly higher in any region. Heart disease and diabetes SMRs were significantly higher in many sub-districts in the north of the country and lower in the south. SMRs for septicemia, influenza/pneumonia, and for cerebrovascular disease were higher in the south. Septicemia was also significantly higher in Tel Aviv and lower in the North, Haifa and Jerusalem districts. SMRs for accidents, particularly for motor vehicle accidents were significantly higher in the peripheral Zefat and Be'er Sheva sub-districts.
The SMR, adjusted for age and ethnicity, is a good method for identifying districts that differ significantly from the national average. Some of the regional differences may be attributed to differences in the completion of death certificates. This needs to be addressed by efforts to improve reporting of causes of death, by educating physicians. The relatively low differences found after adjustment, show that factors associated with ethnicity may affect mortality more than regional factors. Recommendations include encouraging good eating habits, exercise, cancer screening, control of hypertension, reduction of smoking and improving road infrastructure and emergency care access in the periphery.
死亡率的地区差异可用于研究和评估疾病患病率的差异以及导致不同病因的疾病和死亡的因素。为了进行这种比较,对死亡率数据进行标准化以调整地区人口在年龄、国籍和原籍国方面的差异影响非常重要。
计算了以色列各地区和分区的标准化死亡率(SMR),包括按性别划分的总死亡率以及主要死因和选定的特定死因。评估了这些SMR与地区疾病风险因素和社会经济特征之间的相关性。然后研究了对卫生政策的影响。
以色列北部地区的总死亡率与全国平均水平无显著差异;但海法、特拉维夫和南部地区显著较高,而耶路撒冷、中部、朱迪亚和撒马利亚地区较低。耶路撒冷的癌症SMR显著较低,在任何地区均未显著较高。该国北部许多分区的心脏病和糖尿病SMR显著较高,而南部较低。败血症、流感/肺炎和脑血管疾病的SMR在南部较高。败血症在特拉维夫也显著较高,而在北部、海法和耶路撒冷地区较低。事故的SMR,特别是机动车事故的SMR在周边的采法特和贝尔谢巴分区显著较高。
经年龄和种族调整后的SMR是识别与全国平均水平有显著差异的地区的良好方法。一些地区差异可能归因于死亡证明填写的差异。这需要通过努力改善死因报告来解决,通过对医生进行教育。调整后发现的相对较小差异表明,与种族相关的因素可能比地区因素对死亡率的影响更大。建议包括鼓励良好的饮食习惯、运动、癌症筛查、控制高血压、减少吸烟以及改善周边地区的道路基础设施和急救服务。