Drapkina O M, Samorodskaya I V
National Medical Research Center of Therapy and Preventive Medicine, Moscow.
Kardiologiia. 2022 Oct 30;62(10):16-25. doi: 10.18087/cardio.2022.10.n1926.
Aim To analyze the dynamics of standardized mortality ratios (SMR) (2019-2020) for the cardiological causes indicated as the primary (original) cause of death, in regions of the Russian Federation, based on the RF State Statistics Service Brief Nomenclature of Causes of Death (RFSSS BNCD). Reports have indicated substantial changes in the indexes and structure of mortality since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic in many countries.Material and methods RFSSS data on numbers of deaths were analyzed according to BNCD and mid-year population in single year of age groups in 2019 and 2020. SMRs were determined for 23 cardiological causes of death listed in the BNSD in a separate line; the average regional SMR value and the standard deviation were provided; and SMRs were compared both among 4 groups (with a previously described method) and by 23 RFSSS BNCD causes using the Wilcoxon test.Results In 2020 vs. 2019, the mean regional SMR for cardiological causes increased by 12.07±9.86 % (from 301.02±77.67 to 336.15±84.5 %; р<0.0001). Decreases in SMR were found in 9 of 82 regions; however, only in two of them (the Republic of Ingushetia and the Sakhalin Region), SMR was decreased for all 4 groups of causes. In both 2019 and 2020 (60.9±13.8 and 62.5±12.8 %, respectively), the highest proportion of deaths was related with the 1st group of causes (chronic ischemic heart disease, IHD), with an increase in SMR of 18.66±33.28 % (р<0.0001). Increases in SMR were found in 75 regions while in the other regions, decreases in SMRs were observed. For the 2nd group of causes (myocardial infarction, other acute forms of IHD, sudden cardiac death), the mean regional SMR increased in 2020 by 3.2±18.1 % (р=0.3). Increased SMRs were noted in 54 regions. The proportion of the 2nd group in cardiological mortality was 17.3±9.7 % in 2019 and 16.1±9.6 % in 2020. The mean regional SNR for the 3rd group of causes (heart defects, myocardial diseases, etc.) increased in 2020 by 11.6±23.1 % (р=0.006). The mean regional proportion of causes for this group did not significantly changed compared to 2019 (17.5±8.2 and 17.1±7.3 %, respectively); however, the contribution of this group was greater than the contribution of the 2nd group. Increases in SMR were observed in 65 regions, while the contribution of causes related with arterial hypertension did not significantly change. Significant mid-regional differences in SMR values, dynamics of SMRs for different causes, and increases in the coefficient of variation were noted for almost all causes of death. Significant differences between 2019 and 2020 were found for 3 of 23 causes: other forms of chronic IHD (decreased SMRs in 15 regions and increased SMRs in the others), atherosclerotic heart disease (decreased SMRs in 38 regions), and alcoholic cardiomyopathy (decreased SMRs in 28 regions).Conclusion During the COVID-19 pandemic, the SMR for cardiological causes was increased. Considerable regional differences in values and dynamics of SMR for individual causes call for attention to the unification of the criteria for clinical diagnosis.
基于俄罗斯联邦国家统计局死因简要分类法(RFSSS BNCD),分析俄罗斯联邦各地区以心脏病为主要(原始)死因的标准化死亡率(SMR)(2019 - 2020年)动态变化。报告显示,自新冠疫情开始以来,许多国家的死亡率指标和结构发生了重大变化。
根据2019年和2020年按单一年龄组划分的RFSSS死因数据及年中人口数据进行分析。针对BNSD中单独列出的23种心脏病死因确定SMR;提供各地区SMR平均值及标准差;采用先前描述的方法对4组数据进行比较,并使用Wilcoxon检验按23种RFSSS BNCD死因进行比较。
与2019年相比,2020年各地区心脏病死因的平均SMR上升了12.07±9.86%(从301.02±77.67升至336.15±84.5;p<0.0001)。82个地区中有9个地区的SMR下降;然而,其中只有两个地区(印古什共和国和萨哈林地区),所有4组死因的SMR均下降。2019年和2020年(分别为60.9±13.8%和62.5±12.8%),死亡比例最高的是第一组死因(慢性缺血性心脏病,IHD),其SMR上升了18.66±33.28%(p<0.0001)。75个地区的SMR上升,而其他地区则观察到SMR下降。对于第二组死因(心肌梗死、IHD的其他急性形式、心源性猝死),2020年各地区平均SMR上升了3.2±18.1%(p = 0.3)。54个地区的SMR上升。2019年第二组死因在心脏病死亡率中的占比为17.3±9.7%,2020年为16.1±9.6%。第三组死因(心脏缺陷、心肌疾病等)的各地区平均SMR在2020年上升了11.6±23.1%(p = 0.006)。与2019年相比,该组死因在各地区的平均占比没有显著变化(分别为17.5±8.2%和17.1±7.3%);然而,该组的贡献大于第二组。65个地区观察到SMR上升,而与动脉高血压相关死因的贡献没有显著变化。几乎所有死因的SMR值、不同死因的SMR动态变化以及变异系数增加均存在显著的地区差异。23种死因中有3种在2019年和2020年存在显著差异:其他形式的慢性IHD(15个地区SMR下降,其他地区上升)、动脉粥样硬化性心脏病(38个地区SMR下降)和酒精性心肌病(28个地区SMR下降)。
在新冠疫情期间,心脏病死因的SMR上升。各地区个体死因的SMR值和动态变化存在显著差异,需要关注临床诊断标准的统一。