Manduca Paola, Diab Safwat Y, Qouta Samir R, Albarqouni Nabil Ma, Punamaki Raiija-Leena
DISTAV, University of Genoa, Genova, Italy.
Al-Quds Open University-Gaza Branch, Gaza, Gaza Strip, Palestine.
BMJ Open. 2017 Aug 2;7(7):e014035. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014035.
Metal contamination of humans in war areas has rarely been investigated. Weaponry's heavy metals become environmentally stable war remnants and accumulate in living things. They also pose health risks in terms of prenatal intake, with potential long term risks for reproductive and children's health. We studied the contribution of military attacks to the load of 23 metals in the hair of Palestinian women in the Gaza Strip, who were pregnant at the time of the military attacks in 2014, and their newborns. We compared the metal load in the mothers with values for adult hair from outside the war area (RHS) as the reference. We investigated heavy metals trans-passing in utero, and assessed if the heavy metal intake could derive from sources unrelated to the war.
Cross sectional study.
Cross sectional convenience sample of 502 mothers delivering in the Gaza Strip and their newborns.
Measure of the load of heavy metals in mother and newborn hair by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Comparison of metal loads with the reference RHS, between groups with different exposures to attacks and house/agriculture chemicals, and between mothers and newborns. Data for birth registry and for exposures to war and other known risk factors were obtained at interview with the mothers. Photographic documentation of damage from military attacks was obtained.
The whole cross sectional convenience sample had a significantly higher load of heavy metals than the reference RHS. Women exposed to military attacks had a significantly higher load of heavy metals than those not exposed; the load in newborns correlated positively with the mothers' load. No significant difference was found between users/non-users of house/agriculture chemicals. No other known confounder was identified.
High heavy metal loads in mothers, reflected in those of their newborns, were associated with exposure to military attacks, posing a risk of immediate and long term negative outcomes for pregnancy and child health. Surveillance, biomonitoring and further research are recommended. Implications for general and public health are discussed.
战区人类的金属污染情况鲜有研究。武器中的重金属成为环境中稳定的战争残留物并在生物体内累积。它们在产前摄入方面也会带来健康风险,对生殖和儿童健康存在潜在的长期风险。我们研究了军事袭击对2014年军事袭击发生时处于孕期的加沙地带巴勒斯坦妇女及其新生儿头发中23种金属负荷的影响。我们将母亲体内的金属负荷与战区外成年女性头发中的值(右侧对照)进行比较作为参考。我们调查了重金属的子宫内传递情况,并评估重金属摄入是否可能源自与战争无关的来源。
横断面研究。
对在加沙地带分娩的502名母亲及其新生儿进行横断面便利抽样。
通过电感耦合等离子体质谱法(ICP-MS)测量母亲和新生儿头发中的重金属负荷。将金属负荷与右侧对照进行比较,比较不同袭击暴露程度、家庭/农业化学品暴露情况的组之间以及母亲与新生儿之间的金属负荷。在与母亲访谈时获取出生登记数据以及战争暴露和其他已知风险因素的数据。获取军事袭击造成损害的照片记录。
整个横断面便利样本的重金属负荷显著高于右侧对照。遭受军事袭击的妇女的重金属负荷显著高于未遭受袭击的妇女;新生儿体内的负荷与母亲体内的负荷呈正相关。家庭/农业化学品使用者/非使用者之间未发现显著差异。未发现其他已知的混杂因素。
母亲体内的高重金属负荷反映在其新生儿体内,这与军事袭击暴露有关,对妊娠和儿童健康构成即时和长期负面后果的风险。建议进行监测、生物监测和进一步研究。讨论了对一般和公共卫生的影响。