Barnett David W, Barnett Anthony, Nathan Andrea, Van Cauwenberg Jelle, Cerin Ester
Institute for Health and Ageing, Australian Catholic University, Level 6, 215 Spring Street, Melbourne, VIC, 3000, Australia.
Department of Public Health, Ghent University, De Pintelaan 185, 9000, Ghent, Belgium.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2017 Aug 7;14(1):103. doi: 10.1186/s12966-017-0558-z.
Identifying attributes of the built environment associated with health-enhancing levels of physical activity (PA) in older adults (≥65 years old) has the potential to inform interventions supporting healthy and active ageing. The aim of this study was to first systematically review and quantify findings on built environmental correlates of older adults' PA, and second, investigate differences by type of PA and environmental attribute measurement.
One hundred articles from peer-reviewed and grey literature examining built environmental attributes related to total PA met inclusion criteria and relevant information was extracted. Findings were meta-analysed and weighted by article quality and sample size and then stratified by PA and environmental measurement method. Associations (p < .05) were found in relation to 26 individual built environmental attributes across six categories (walkability, residential density/urbanisation, street connectivity, access to/availability of destinations and services, infrastructure and streetscape, and safety) and total PA and walking specifically. Reported individual- and environmental-level moderators were also examined.
Positive environmental correlates of PA, ranked by strength of evidence, were: walkability (p < .001), safety from crime (p < .001), overall access to destinations and services (p < .001), recreational facilities (p < .001), parks/public open space (p = .002) and shops/commercial destinations (p = .006), greenery and aesthetically pleasing scenery (p = .004), walk-friendly infrastructure (p = .009), and access to public transport (p = .016). There were 26 individual differences in the number of significant associations when the type of PA and environmental measurement method was considered. No consistent moderating effects on the association between built environmental attributes and PA were found.
Safe, walkable, and aesthetically pleasing neighbourhoods, with access to overall and specific destinations and services positively influenced older adults' PA participation. However, when considering the environmental attributes that were sufficiently studied (i.e., in ≥5 separate findings), the strength of evidence of associations of specific categories of environment attributes with PA differed across PA and environmental measurement types. Future research should be mindful of these differences in findings and identify the underlying mechanisms. Higher quality research is also needed.
确定与老年人(≥65岁)健康增强型身体活动(PA)水平相关的建成环境属性,有可能为支持健康和积极老龄化的干预措施提供信息。本研究的目的,一是系统回顾和量化关于老年人身体活动与建成环境相关性的研究结果,二是调查身体活动类型和环境属性测量方法的差异。
从同行评审和灰色文献中筛选出100篇研究建成环境属性与总身体活动相关性的文章,提取相关信息。研究结果采用Meta分析,并根据文章质量和样本量进行加权,然后按身体活动类型和环境测量方法进行分层。在六个类别(步行适宜性、居住密度/城市化、街道连通性、目的地和服务的可达性/可用性、基础设施和街道景观以及安全性)的26个个体建成环境属性与总身体活动及特定的步行活动之间发现了相关性(p < 0.05)。还对报告的个体和环境层面的调节因素进行了研究。
按证据强度排序,与身体活动呈正相关的环境因素为:步行适宜性(p < 0.001)、犯罪安全性(p < 0.001)、目的地和服务的总体可达性(p < 0.001)、娱乐设施(p < 0.001)、公园/公共开放空间(p = 0.002)和商店/商业目的地(p = 0.006)、绿化和美观的风景(p = 0.004)、利于步行的基础设施(p = 0.009)以及公共交通可达性(p = 0.016)。考虑身体活动类型和环境测量方法时,显著关联的数量存在26个个体差异。未发现对建成环境属性与身体活动之间的关联有一致的调节作用。
安全、适宜步行且美观的社区,以及能到达各类总体和特定目的地及服务场所,对老年人参与身体活动有积极影响。然而,在考虑经过充分研究的环境属性(即有≥5项独立研究结果)时,特定类别的环境属性与身体活动之间关联的证据强度因身体活动类型和环境测量类型而异。未来的研究应注意这些研究结果的差异,并确定其潜在机制。还需要更高质量的研究。