Subramanian Indu
UCLA/West LA VA, Los Angeles, CA, United States.
Int Rev Neurobiol. 2017;134:1163-1188. doi: 10.1016/bs.irn.2017.05.037. Epub 2017 Jul 14.
The use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapy in nonmotor symptoms (NMS) for Parkinson disease (PD) is growing worldwide. Well-performed, systematic evidence-based research is largely lacking in this area and many studies include various forms of CAM with small patient numbers and a lack of standardization of the approaches studied. Taichi, Qigong, dance, yoga, mindfulness, acupuncture, and other CAM therapies are reviewed and there is some evidence for the following: Taichi in sleep and PDQ39; dance in cognition, apathy, and a mild trend to improved fatigue; yoga in PDQ39; and acupuncture in depression, PDQ39, and sleep. Exercise including occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) has been studied in motor symptoms of PD and balance but only with small studies with a mounting evidence base for use of exercise in NMS of PD including PDQ39, sleep, fatigue, depression, and some subsets of cognition. Studies of OT and PT largely show some benefit to depression, apathy, and anxiety. Sustainability of an improvement has not been shown given short duration of follow up. Finding optimal control groups and blind for these interventions is also an issue. This is a very important area of study since patients want to be self-empowered and they want guidance on which form of exercise is the best. Additionally, evidence for PT and OT in NMS would give added weight to get these interventions covered through medical insurance.
在全球范围内,补充和替代医学(CAM)疗法在帕金森病(PD)非运动症状(NMS)中的应用正在增加。该领域在很大程度上缺乏执行良好、基于系统证据的研究,许多研究纳入了各种形式的补充和替代医学,患者数量少,且所研究方法缺乏标准化。本文综述了太极拳、气功、舞蹈、瑜伽、正念减压疗法、针灸及其他补充和替代医学疗法,有证据支持以下方面:太极拳对睡眠和帕金森病问卷39项(PDQ39)有作用;舞蹈对认知、淡漠有作用,且对改善疲劳有轻微趋势;瑜伽对PDQ39有作用;针灸对抑郁、PDQ39和睡眠有作用。包括职业治疗(OT)和物理治疗(PT)在内的运动已在帕金森病的运动症状和平衡方面进行了研究,但仅有小规模研究,且越来越多的证据表明运动对帕金森病非运动症状(包括PDQ39、睡眠、疲劳、抑郁及部分认知亚组)有作用。职业治疗和物理治疗的研究大多显示对抑郁、淡漠和焦虑有一定益处。鉴于随访时间短,尚未显示改善的可持续性。为这些干预措施找到最佳对照组并实施盲法也是一个问题。这是一个非常重要的研究领域,因为患者希望自我赋能,他们希望得到关于哪种运动形式最佳的指导。此外,关于职业治疗和物理治疗在非运动症状方面的证据将更有力地促使这些干预措施纳入医疗保险覆盖范围。