Donohoe Claire L, Reynolds John V
Department of Surgery, St. James's Hospital and Trinity College Dublin, Ireland.
J Thorac Dis. 2017 Jul;9(Suppl 8):S697-S704. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2017.03.159.
Recent trials, including CROSS, MAGIC, ACCORD, and OEO2, have established neoadjuvant therapy as standard of care for locally advanced (cTNM) esophageal and junctional cancer compared with surgery alone. The CROSS trial in particular defines a new benchmark for outcomes from multimodal therapy, with a 5 year survival rate of 47%, a median survival of 47 months, a pathologic complete response rate (pCR) of 29% and an R0 resection rate of 92%. Several key questions remain, in particular whether CROSS-regimen chemoradiotherapy is superior to neoadjuvant chemotherapy alone for esophageal cancer, in particular adenocarcinoma. Second, with respect to neoadjuvant chemoradiation, whether an apparent complete clinical response can justify a "watch and wait" surveillance policy, with salvage surgery reserved for where relapse occurs. Third, whether with modern staging, predicted node negative cT2 tumors merit neoadjuvant therapy as standard. Finally, with the enormous interest in the application of targeted and immune-based therapies, and positive leads from other cancers, whether such approaches can improve outcomes in patients undergoing treatment with curative intent. We review herein a brief overview of the existing evidence-base and current active trials addressing these key questions.
近期的试验,包括CROSS、MAGIC、ACCORD和OEO2试验,已确立新辅助治疗作为局部晚期(cTNM)食管癌和食管交界癌的标准治疗方案,优于单纯手术治疗。特别是CROSS试验为多模式治疗的结果定义了一个新的基准,5年生存率为47%,中位生存期为47个月,病理完全缓解率(pCR)为29%,R0切除率为92%。仍有几个关键问题存在,尤其是CROSS方案的放化疗对于食管癌,特别是腺癌,是否优于单纯新辅助化疗。其次,对于新辅助放化疗,明显的临床完全缓解是否足以证明“观察等待”监测策略的合理性,仅在复发时进行挽救性手术。第三,对于现代分期,预测为淋巴结阴性的cT2肿瘤作为标准是否值得进行新辅助治疗。最后,鉴于对靶向治疗和免疫治疗应用的巨大兴趣,以及其他癌症的积极线索,此类方法是否能改善接受根治性治疗患者的预后。我们在此简要回顾解决这些关键问题的现有证据基础和当前正在进行的试验。