Narayan Mary Curry, Scafide Katherine N
1 George Mason University School of Nursing, Fairfax, VA, USA.
J Transcult Nurs. 2017 Nov;28(6):598-607. doi: 10.1177/1043659617700710. Epub 2017 Mar 26.
Though extensive evidence demonstrates that U.S. minority patients suffer health care disparities, the incidence of disparities among the 3.3 million adult patients receiving skilled intermittent home health care services annually is unclear. The purpose of this systematic review is to determine the relationship of race/ethnicity on home health care patient outcomes.
PRISMA guidelines were used to perform a systematic search of the literature within the CINHAL, Medline, and Web of Science databases. Search terms included variations on the terms: home health, minority race/ethnicity, and patient outcomes. Included studies evaluated adult patient outcomes to intermittent skilled home health care services from Medicare-certified agencies using federally defined race/ethnicity categories. Research quality was evaluated using the Johns Hopkins Evidence Based Practice Grading Scale.
Seven studies were identified in the search. All studies were of good-to-high quality with the majority having large samples. All seven found a significant difference in patient outcomes related to race/ethnicity. Specifically, minority patients had more adverse events, less improvement in functional outcomes, and worse patient experiences when compared with majority patients.
Home health care disparities exist and efforts should be made to provide culturally and linguistically appropriate care to all patients.
尽管大量证据表明美国少数族裔患者面临医疗保健差异,但每年接受熟练间歇性家庭医疗服务的330万成年患者中差异的发生率尚不清楚。本系统评价的目的是确定种族/民族与家庭医疗患者结局之间的关系。
采用PRISMA指南对CINHAL、Medline和科学网数据库中的文献进行系统检索。检索词包括以下术语的变体:家庭医疗、少数族裔、患者结局。纳入的研究使用联邦定义的种族/民族类别,评估了医疗保险认证机构提供的间歇性熟练家庭医疗服务的成年患者结局。使用约翰霍普金斯循证实践分级量表评估研究质量。
检索中识别出7项研究。所有研究质量良好至高,大多数样本量较大。所有7项研究均发现与种族/民族相关的患者结局存在显著差异。具体而言,与多数族裔患者相比,少数族裔患者有更多不良事件、功能结局改善较少且患者体验较差。
家庭医疗存在差异,应努力为所有患者提供文化和语言适宜的护理。