Gallena Sally J K, Stickels Betsy, Stickels Emily
Speech-Language-Hearing Sciences, Loyola University MD, Baltimore, Maryland.
Speech-Language-Hearing Sciences, Loyola University MD, Baltimore, Maryland; Language and Voice Experience, Rockville, Maryland.
J Voice. 2018 Sep;32(5):592-601. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2017.06.023. Epub 2017 Aug 24.
Voice feminization therapy for male-to-female transgender women typically targets increasing fundamental frequency (F). Increasing vowel formant frequencies (FFs) has also been proposed. To better understand formant conditions that shift listeners' perception of gender from male to "not-male," individual and combined vowel FFs were incrementally raised, whereas F was held constant at a gender-ambiguous level.
The study used a prospective, experimental group design. Using a customized MATLAB program, vowels (/i/, /æ/, /ɑ/, and /u/) spoken by an adult were manipulated by isolating and increasing FF until they matched those of a woman. Listeners heard randomized samples and perceptually categorized each as male, female, or gender neutral. The latter two choices were combined and labeled not-male.
Chi-square analyses revealed that listeners rated samples as not-male for /ɑ/ and /æ/ with all three formants shifted or individual formants shifted at >60%. Individual analysis of vowels, formants, and shifted FF using Kruskal-Wallis revealed a statistical significance for vowels only.
Results suggest that voice was convincingly perceived as not-male, for vowels characterized by a high F frequency, and that raising FFs for all four vowels increased (in varying amounts) the perception of voice femininity beyond that of raising F alone.
针对男变女跨性别女性的嗓音女性化治疗通常旨在提高基频(F)。也有人提出要提高元音共振峰频率(FFs)。为了更好地理解能使听众对性别的感知从男性转变为“非男性”的共振峰条件,我们逐步提高单个元音和组合元音的FFs,同时将F保持在一个性别模糊的水平。
本研究采用前瞻性实验组设计。使用定制的MATLAB程序,通过分离并提高FFs,对一名成年人说出的元音(/i/、/æ/、/ɑ/和/u/)进行处理,直到它们与女性的元音相匹配。听众听取随机样本,并在感知上将每个样本归类为男性、女性或性别中性。后两种选择合并并标记为非男性。
卡方分析显示,对于/ɑ/和/æ/,当所有三个共振峰都发生偏移或单个共振峰偏移超过60%时,听众将样本评为非男性。使用Kruskal-Wallis对元音、共振峰和偏移的FFs进行单独分析,结果显示仅元音具有统计学意义。
结果表明,对于以高F频率为特征的元音,嗓音被令人信服地感知为非男性,并且提高所有四个元音的FFs(幅度各不相同)比单独提高F更能增强嗓音女性化的感知。