Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Virginia Tech , 418 Durham Hall, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061, United States.
Environ Sci Technol. 2017 Oct 17;51(20):11986-11995. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.7b01589. Epub 2017 Sep 26.
We hypothesize that the increase in reported Legionnaires' disease from June 2014 to November 2015 in Genesee County, MI (where Flint is located) was directly linked to the switch to corrosive Flint River water from noncorrosive Detroit water from April 2014 to October 2015. To address the lack of epidemiological data linking the drinking water supplies to disease incidence, we gathered physiochemical and biological water quality data from 2010 to 2016 to evaluate characteristics of the Flint River water that were potentially conducive to Legionella growth. The treated Flint River water was 8.6 times more corrosive than Detroit water in short-term testing, releasing more iron, which is a key Legionella nutrient, while also directly causing disinfectant to decay more rapidly. The Flint River water source was also 0.8-6.7 °C warmer in summer months than Detroit water and exceeded the minimum Legionella growth temperature of 20 °C more frequently (average number of days per year for Detroit was 63 versus that for the Flint River, which was 157). The corrosive water also led to 1.3-2.2 times more water main breaks in 2014-2015 compared to 2010-2013; such disruptions have been associated with outbreaks in other locales. Importantly, Legionella spp. and Legionella pneumophila decreased after switching back to Detroit water, in terms of both gene markers and culturability, when August and October 2015 were compared to November 2016.
我们假设密歇根州格奈斯县(弗林特所在的地区)2014 年 6 月至 2015 年 11 月报告的军团病病例增加与 2014 年 4 月至 2015 年 10 月弗林特从腐蚀性的弗林特河水切换到非腐蚀性的底特律水直接相关。为了解决缺乏将饮用水供应与疾病发病率联系起来的流行病学数据的问题,我们从 2010 年到 2016 年收集了理化和生物水质数据,以评估可能有利于军团菌生长的弗林特河水的特征。在短期测试中,处理过的弗林特河水比底特律河水腐蚀性强 8.6 倍,释放出更多的铁,这是军团菌的关键营养物质,同时也直接导致消毒剂更快地衰减。弗林特河水源在夏季比底特律河温暖 0.8-6.7°C,而且更频繁地超过了军团菌生长的最低温度 20°C(底特律河每年有 63 天,而弗林特河有 157 天)。腐蚀性的水还导致 2014-2015 年比 2010-2013 年同期的水管破裂增加了 1.3-2.2 倍;这种中断与其他地方的爆发有关。重要的是,从底特律水切换回来后,军团菌属和嗜肺军团菌的基因标记和可培养性都有所下降,2015 年 8 月和 10 月与 2015 年 11 月相比。